Also: Bad U.S. economic data, Samsung's CHIPS grant, Nippon defends itself.
Good morning.
When the Supreme Court struck down race-based admissions at U.S. universities last year, it was only a matter of time before attention turned to legacy admissions—the practice of giving preference to applicants whose family members are alumni. Sure enough, Connecticut lawmakers are now advancing a bill to ban the use of legacy and donor preferences in admissions to all colleges and universities across the state, including Yale University. Virginia’s ban on legacy admissions at public universities was signed into law last week. (Colorado banned the practice in 2021.)
The popularity of legacy admissions has everything to do with brand. These are coveted slots because they are proven catalysts for success. The practice of giving legacy candidates a boost is especially prevalent among elite private institutions. At Harvard, for example, legacy students make up less than 5% of applicants but are around 30% of those admitted. It’s been a successful loyalty program that’s increasingly perceived as toxic to the brand. Harvard is now being sued over its legacy policies, having been targeted for race-based policies.
For companies that have been struggling with the implications of affirmative action rulings on DEI, chipping away at legacy admissions could be a good thing. Many of the CEOs I talk to want to increase diversity in their companies and address inequality in society. The challenge is that it’s become harder to talk about and legally trickier to pursue. Many leaders felt forced to scale back race-based hiring programs after the Supreme Court ruling, with some removing racial criteria for applicants altogether. Recruiting from schools accused of bolstering privilege doesn’t help in this environment.
Competitive schools tend to attract high-performing students who can be terrific employees. Those students suffer when people think they’re there because of mom or dad. Employers suffer when it looks like the system is rigged. The erosion of legacy admission could strengthen the credibility and diversity of top-tier schools, from which many employers recruit.
Let’s face it: There are a lot of great schools out there that groom a lot of great leaders. Of the 2023 Fortune 100 CEOs, only 11.8% attended an Ivy as undergrads, and only 9.8% hold an Ivy League MBA, according to Dartmouth professor David Kang.
The data underscores a point that Jack Welch, the former chief executive of GE, made in one of my first interviews with a CEO. He preferred to hire people who were at the top of their class in a public university than an Ivy League grad because he felt it was a sign of talent and grit. There’s plenty of talent and grit at Ivy League schools. Without legacies to cloud the debate, it’s easier to see.
Diane Brady
@dianebrady
diane.brady@fortune.com
|
|
|
A one-two punch
The U.S. released two sets of worse-than-expected economic data on Thursday. Retail sales rose just 0.6% month-on-month in February, weaker than forecast. “Perhaps the consumer is not as healthy as expected,” Damian McIntyre, portfolio manager at Federated Hermes, says. Producer prices rose by 0.6%, steeper than expected, which may encourage the Federal Reserve to delay cutting interest rates. Fortune
Samsung gets a CHIPS grant
Korean chipmaker Samsung Electronics will get $6 billion in U.S. grants to expand operations beyond the company’s under-construction $17 billion Texas plant, according to sources. The Biden administration is planning to announce more CHIPS Act grants in the coming weeks, including a reported $5 billion grant to TSMC and a grant worth more than $10 billion for Intel. Bloomberg
Nippon Steel defends itself
Nippon Steel says its proposed purchase of U.S. Steel will bolster “economic defenses against China” as the Japanese company tries to assuage political opposition to the $14.9 billion deal. President Joe Biden came out against the deal on Thursday, saying he preferred that U.S. Steel remain U.S.-owned. Nippon Steel said it was still determined to acquire U.S. Steel, despite opposition from Biden and steelworking unions. Nikkei Asia
|
|
|
2024: A New Era for Consumer Products While price increases during the height of inflation were granted some sympathy, Deloitte’s 2024 Consumer Product Outlook explains that as price-taking runs its course, the industry may turn to profitable volume. Read more.
|
|
|
CFO Daily is a must-read for finance professionals Stay abreast of the news, trends, and executives shaping corporate finance with our free daily newsletter. Sign up now |
|
|
Thanks for reading. If you liked this email, pay it forward. Share it with someone you know. Did someone share this with you? Sign up here. For previous editions, click here.
To view all of Fortune's newsletters on the latest in business, go here.
|
|
|
|
 |
