The taxpayers’ cost of redistricting fights

From: POLITICO New York Playbook PM - Friday Jan 12,2024 09:04 pm
Your afternoon must-read briefing informing the daily conversation among knowledgeable New Yorkers
Jan 12, 2024 View in browser
 
POLITICO New York Playbook PM

By Bill Mahoney

With help from Jason Beeferman

A cyclist rides past the New York Court of Appeals.

New York Court of Appeals in Albany. The court ruled in December that officials must revisit the state's congressional maps. | Hans Pennink/AP

New York’s never ending redistricting process could wind up costing state taxpayers tens of millions of dollars.

A December decision from the Court of Appeals ordered officials to revisit the state’s congressional maps, guaranteeing a process that started in early 2020 will drag on for at least four years.

New York’s Independent Redistricting Commission approved a new contract with a consulting group that has helped it draw the lines at a planning meeting after the December ruling.

So that bumps the total value of redistricting contracts that the state has signed with outside entities to over $7 million, according to records obtained by Playbook from the state Comptroller’s Office.

Most of that money has been spent on lawyers.

The state Senate has a contract worth up to $3 million with the Manhattan firm Cuti Hecker Wang to represent the chamber in redistricting litigation; the Assembly has a similar one worth $1.5 million with Graubard Miller. Two other firms separately represent Democrats and Republicans on the IRC, for around $700,000 each.

But that $7 million doesn’t include the in-house money the state has spent. Lawyers from the Attorney General’s Office have represented Gov. Kathy Hochul in redistricting cases over the past two years.

The IRC itself, meanwhile, has received a combined $10 million in the past three state budgets – and will likely receive more in the proposal that will be released next week.

And the Legislative Task Force on Demographic Research and Reapportionment, which handled mapmaking in prior decades and still exists to play some supporting roles in the process, has had budget lines of as much as $2 million each year. — Bill Mahoney

PROGRAMMING NOTE: There will be no New York Playbook on Monday, Martin Luther King Jr. Day. Thank you for reading as always! We’ll be back in your inboxes on Tuesday, budget day.

From the Capitol

Governor Kathy Hochul delivers remarks at the rally for Israeli hostages in Manhattan.

Governor Kathy Hochul voiced her steadfast support for Israel Friday at a rally to mark nearly 100 days since Israeli hostages have been held in Hamas captivity. | Susan Watts/Office of Governor Kathy Hochul

HOCHUL’S HOSTAGE PLEA: It’s been nearly 100 days since Hamas kidnapped hundreds of civilians in Israel and took them hostage inside Gaza, some of them U.S. citizens.

At a rally for their release earlier this morning, Hochul demanded the freeing of the hostages and described her visit to the battered Kibbutz Kfar Aza, where she said she was the first elected to step foot in the southern Israel community.

“Hamas is a terrorist organization that must be stopped because if we don't stop them where they did this, they will continue; they will continue their scourge to destroy the Jewish people and others,” the governor said, speaking blocks away from the United Nations and the Israeli Consulate in Manhattan.

“The people of Israel have a right to defend themselves, and they have a right to bring the hostages home.”

The steadfast support comes as increasing pressure has mounted on Israel both internally, from the Biden administration, and publicly, at the Hague, to halt its military’s intense bombing campaign and ground assault on Gaza.

Hochul, meanwhile, has not wavered in her support for the nation.

“Yes, we mourn the loss of any innocent life, but the people who are dancing at a concert so joyfully, the people who were in their homes, the people just waking up to start a new day to celebrate the holy day… I want the hostages brought home, and I want the rest of the world to start saying the same thing.” — Jason Beeferman

HOCHUL BACKS DEATH PENALTY FOR BUFFALO SHOOTER: Hochul supports the Department of Justice’s pursuit of the death penalty for the man convicted of shooting 10 people at a Buffalo supermarket in 2022.

The DOJ on Friday in a court filing argued Payton Gendron’s purposeful targeting of Black people in the racially motivated attack warranted the death penalty.

Hochul, speaking with reporters at a storm briefing, agreed with the move.

“This community is still reeling from the atrocity of 10 innocent people on May 14 in 2022 simply going about shopping and were targeted because of the color of their skin by a white supremacist who was radicalized online,” Hochul, a Western New York native, said. “So, I suppose the Department of Justice.”

Hochul has previously backed efforts to bolster the State Police’s monitoring of hate speech online as well as an expansion of the state’s red flag in order to keep guns away from people deemed to be dangerous. – Nick Reisman

FROM CITY HALL

Mayor Eric Adams in City Hall Friday, January 12, 2024.

Mayor Eric Adams announced Friday that $10 million in funding will be restored to community schools and $80 million will be committed to the city's portion of the program. | Ed Reed/Mayoral Photography Office

EDUCATION UNCUTS: The city is reversing cuts to community schools and making new investments in a popular summer learning and enrichment program, Mayor Eric Adams announced.

The Adams administration is restoring $10 million for community schools, which work with local organizations to offer services like health care, mentoring and adult education. That money will be spread across 170 community schools.

And for the first time, the city Department of Education will cover its $80 million portion of the program, which the previous administration funded using temporary federal Covid-19 stimulus dollars. (The DOE and the Department of Youth and Community Development jointly administer the program).

“We want to be extremely, extremely clear that we know it takes an entire city to raise a child and through community schools and the Summer rising program, we’re giving our young people a chance to learn and grow,” Adams said during a press conference at City Hall.

As part of the November budget modification plan, the city reduced the hours for about 30,000 middle school slots (as such students often underutilize summer services).

Both the DOE and DYCD still have to trim their budgets as part of the next round of cuts, but the about-face is the latest in a series of budget cut reversals Adams enacted this week,

They include restorations to the sanitation and parks departments as well as the NYPD and FDNY. The latest announcement comes after the city’s teachers union sued Adams to stop cuts to education funding.

“Good, now keep going,” United Federation of Teachers President Michael Mulgrew said in a statement. — Madina Touré

On the Beats

This photograph taken on October 13, 2023 shows the crown of oaks (Quercus petraea) in the "Reseau national de suivi à long terme des ecosystemes forestiers" (RENECOFOR - National network for long-term monitoring of forest ecosystems) plot in the Mouliere state forest, near Poitiers, western France. The ONF (Forest National Office) studies the implementation of a management strategy called mosaic forest to fight global warming and assist the long-term development of species in French forests. (Photo by GUILLAUME SOUVANT / AFP) (Photo by GUILLAUME SOUVANT/AFP via Getty Images)

Gov. Kathy Hochul is hoping to plant 25 million trees as a way to fight extreme heat in New York state. | AFP via Getty Images

ENVIRONMENT: Hochul wants to plant 25 million trees by 2033 as part of an initiative to combat extreme heat, but first, she needs a strategy.

That’s from Alexander Kobald, an associate director of the Design Across Scales Lab at the at Cornell University. He helped design “Tree Folio NYC,” a “digital twin of New York City’s tree canopy.” The design demonstrates where trees provide the most shade and where it would be needed most.

“The state of New York’s tree planting program is an exciting investment that is certainly needed in urban areas throughout the state,” he said in a statement. “However, making the most of new tree planting is critical.” – Shawn Ness

RIVER CLEANUP: Local officials are pushing for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to decide that the dredging of the Hudson River didn’t fully protect human health. They sent a letter earlier this week urging the EPA to make the determination as part of the delayed, five-year review process.

“The data trends clearly indicate that the selected remedy is not on track to meet the goals needed to protect human or ecological health,” the officials wrote.

The EPA is undertaking a third five-year review of the effectiveness of General Electric’s dredgin g to remove toxic PCBs the company dumped in the river. The last review deferred a decision on whether the dredging effectively protected human health, pending additional data.

Environmental advocates have argued, based on the available data, that the river is not on track to meet the targeted levels of contamination in fish that the EPA thought would result from the dredging effort.

“Fishing has been observed and fish are being consumed, putting a particularly unjust burden on those who rely on fish for subsistence,” the officials wrote.

The community advisory group for the Hudson River Superfund cleanup is set to meet Jan. 18, and the EPA will likely provide an update on the review. The EPA plans to release the draft of the five-year review, which includes data collected from 2017 to 2021, early this year. Marie J. French

CLOSING A LOOPHOLE: Advocates for survivors of sexual assault are hoping a suite of bills aiming to bring justice to victims will be passed in Albany this session.

The push comes just two months after the Adult Survivors Act expired in late November. That bill gave survivors of sexual assault a year-long suspension of the statue of limitations on sexual assault and misconduct, enabling lawsuits against big names like Sean Combs, Harvey Weinstein and Donald Trump.

Perhaps the most significant legislation survivors’ advocates are looking to pass this year is the “Voluntary Intoxication Loophole Bill,” which prevents accused perpetrators of rape from using a victim’s voluntary intoxication as a defense.

“I don't think any of us in New York State walk around thinking this is actually the state of the law,” said Lizzie Asher, president of Cura Collective, a group advocating for the passage of the bills, S4555A and A1065, which are sponsored by lawmakers Nathalia Fernandez and Jeffrey Dinowitz.

Asher pointed to a 2009 case where two NYPD officers were acquitted of rape under the loophole and noted how other states like Minnesota and North Carolina have put measures in place to close it.

“In what other crime where you are the victim, if you are intoxicated, the person who inflicted harm gets a pass?” Asher said. — Jason Beeferman

HOUSING: Housing costs in the New York City region have jumped more than 68 percent in the last decade – outpacing other cities, according to a new report from state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli.

The increase has put significant strain on residents, and it comes amid a slowdown in development as New York faces a housing shortage, the report noted.

Homeowners and renters in the city and surrounding counties spent $30,300 on average on housing in 2021 and 2022 – an all-time high surpassed only by the San Francisco and Seattle metro areas. The sum, which included costs around shelter, utilities, maintenance and furnishings, made up 40 percent of households’ total expenses.

Meanwhile, as of October 2023, nearly a fifth of city residents were behind on their rent, compared to 12 percent nationally, the report said. And 53 percent of households – some 1 million tenants – were rent-burdened in 2021, meaning they spent more than 30 percent of their income on rent.

The report attributed the slowdown in housing development to high interest rates and the lapse of the 421-a tax incentive, which expired in 2022.

“City and state leaders recognize New York’s housing affordability problem but need to implement cost-effective solutions more quickly,” DiNapoli said in a statement. — Janaki Chadha

GAMBLING GLUT: The state has collected over $1.5 billion in mobile sports betting taxes – two years since the bets became legal in New York.

Most of the money goes toward state education funds. The state collected an additional $200 million in licensing fees during 2022, which brings total state revenue to $1.75 billion since its Jan. 2022 legalization took effect.

The state said the figure “shattered national records for mobile sports wagering” and ranks in revenue overall only behind New Jersey and Nevada, which have had sports betting well before New York.

“New York is the clear leader in providing responsible entertainment for millions while bringing in record-shattering revenue for education, youth sports, and problem gambling prevention," Hochul said in a statement. "I look forward to this third year of our successful gaming policies

CANNABIS: New York cannabis regulators approved two medical marijuana operators to enter the adult-use market today after not acting on a similar agenda item during a contentious Dec. 29 meeting.

Fiorello Pharmaceuticals, owned by Green Thumb Industries, and Citiva Medical, owned by iAnthus Holdings, got the go ahead from three Cannabis Control Board members to co-locate recreational marijuana sales with one of their medical marijuana dispensaries.

So far, the only medical marijuana operator who has paid the $5 million initial fee to launch adult-use sales is Pharmacann. — Mona Zhang

AROUND NEW YORK

— Hochul will release her budget plan on Tuesday with support for migrants under scrutiny. (POLITICO)

Albany’s hottest new bar, Todd Shapiro’s “The War Room,” gets its New York Times treatment.

A brief history of Deputy Mayor Phill Bank’s public safety briefings. (City & State)

 

Follow us on Twitter

Joseph Spector @JoeSpectorNY

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

| Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

More emails from POLITICO New York Playbook PM

Jan 11,2024 09:01 pm - Thursday

Hochul doubles down on mental health

Jan 10,2024 08:51 pm - Wednesday

A bigger bottle bill, again?

Jan 09,2024 09:22 pm - Tuesday

Hochul's 2024 plans

Jan 08,2024 09:36 pm - Monday

Hochul’s plan for AI in New York

Jun 09,2023 09:21 pm - Friday

New York pols divided on Trump

Jun 08,2023 09:20 pm - Thursday

New union contracts arrive

Jun 07,2023 09:29 pm - Wednesday

Adams sues most of NY