The showdown we've all been waiting for

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Thursday Dec 09,2021 11:02 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Dec 09, 2021 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Nick Taylor-Vaisey

Send tips | Subscribe here | Follow Politico Canada

WELCOME TO OTTAWA PLAYBOOK. I'm your host, Nick Taylor-Vaisey. It's Thursday, and everything is happening. Three watchdogs are in action today. We're about to get a dollop of House committee assignments. And then there's the main event featuring the finance minister and a certain fierce critic on the Tory bench. Reminder: seven sitting days remain. Number of bills passed into law: 1.

Driving the Day

FREELAND AT FINA — Anyone who has watched PIERRE POILIEVRE in action knows he’s been counting the days until his first extended showdown with the finance minister since the election. Poilievre has sparred with her in QP, but Freeland is set for a two-hour visit to the House finance committee in Room 035-B of West Block. Set an alarm for 11 a.m.

This isn't the first Freeland vs. Poilievre bout. The pair dueled over Bank of Canada independence at the same committee last year. Expect that to come up today, by the way, as the relentless Tory throws everything at the wall: out-of-control inflation, an aloof TIFF MACKLEM , money printing, runaway debt, a skyrocketing housing market and — in his preferred economic parlance — too many dollars chasing too few goods.

The actual topic of conversation is Bill C-2, the legislation that would spend C$7 billion on Covid aid for those hardest-hit by the pandemic. The ask is a fraction of the original CERB and wage subsidy, but the price tag on the table once marked a hefty sum in the Before Times.

— The prelude: Poilievre has been building to this moment. On Tuesday, he badgered a phalanx of public servants for an answer to a simple question: Where are they finding seven billion bucks? The MP for Carleton was once a Cabinet minister: he knows how funding approvals work. He also knows the bureaucrats on the call — all 10 of them — were tasked with answering specific technical details about the government's proposed programs.

But his basic question is valid. Liberal MP JULIE DZEROWICZ admitted as much when she suggested Poilievre ask the same thing of Freeland when she testifies this morning.

— His real motivation: Poilievre is the face of the Tory front bench's attacks on the Trudeau government's economic record. During the summer campaign, he put out an ad — on actual television, not just social media — that came with a catchy catchphrase of his own: "Paycheques, not debt. Make more, cost less." Those words didn't appear in ERIN O'TOOLE's ads. And Poilievre is still using the same rhetoric in the Commons.

When his opening barrage of committee questions targeted the public servants on the call, it was clear that he sought confusion and obfuscation — anything but a clear answer. He wanted a delicious clip for his followers. When his questions produced dead air, he got the clip (complete with Jeopardy! theme music). A lot of Liberals and plenty of economists will scoff, but Poilievre's 127,000 s are watching — more than 30,000 views in am afternoon and evening — and this was a stuffy committee meeting.

— More fireworks: Poilievre will ask the same basic question to Freeland. If she has a clear answer about the Rube Goldberg Machine that produces program funding estimates, Poilievre may not get his clip. But Playbook predicts he'll find a way.

If your name is CHRYSTIA FREELAND and you're reading this newsletter, feel free to drop us a copy of your speaking notes this morning. We'll keep them to ourselves!

DAYS WITH NO DOCS: 44 — More than a month has passed since Cabinet was sworn in, and still the Prime Minister's Office has made no mention of new mandate letters for ministers. Playbook is counting.

Treasury Board President MONA FORTIER told a Senate committee that she expects her mandate letter "very soon." Playbook heard a rumor they'd be published this week. Count us skeptical. Keep an eye out next week.

TOLD YA SO — That might be ERIN O'TOOLE's framing of the Liberal government's decision to join the United States, United Kingdom, Australia and New Zealand in refusing to send a political delegation to the Beijing games in February.

O'Toole has been calling for a diplomatic boycott for several days. As he left his national caucus meeting Wednesday shortly before Trudeau's comments, the Tory leader re-upped his call.

"At this stage a year ago we called for democratic countries to work at relocating the Games, moving them and even maybe offering Canada to be part of that," he said. "There was no traction with Mr. Trudeau, so I hope today he takes the lead of the Conservative opposition and some of our allies calling for a diplomatic boycott."

— Building the coalition: Foreign Minister MÉLANIE JOLY told reporters that Canada would lobby other countries to take similar action — the language of multilateralism now second nature to the Trudeau government.

The boycotters are so far Anglo-majority nations. Joly's challenge will be swaying the rest of Canada's allies.

To that point: Joly said she'd raise the boycott at the G-7 foreign ministers' meetings this weekend in the U.K. My colleague ANDY BLATCHFORD has more reporting on the boycott.

INFIGHTING ON THE LEFT — The NDP's star candidate in B.C., AVI LEWIS, finished third in West Vancouver–Sunshine Coast–Sea to Sky Country. But he's not going quietly into the night. Lewis is actively promoting a movement among grassroots New Dems to call on the B.C. NDP government to remove the RCMP from the land of the Wet'suwet'en people.

— Hill support: At least three NDP MPs have signed on: LEAH GAZAN, LORI IDLOUT and MATTHEW GREEN. Former MP ROMEO SAGANASH is also onboard, along with recent candidates ANGELLA MACEWEN and PAUL TAYLOR.

The party's leader, JAGMEET SINGH, has long steered clear of openly opposing B.C. Premier JOHN HORGAN 's government. But 12 percent of his own modest-sized caucus now wants more.

AROUND THE HILL

AT LAST, COMMITTEES — The procedure and House affairs committee — PROC for short — will likely table a report this morning that sets the membership of every Commons standing committee. We'll be refreshing PROC's website every five minutes. Keep an eye on our Twitter feed.

— The hierarchy: Friday's Playbook will take stock of the who's who on each committee and identify — IN BOLD AND UPPER CASE — all of the likely chair contenders. It's a last gasp for any Liberal who hasn't yet scored a plum gig in addition to regular backbench duties. (A handful of committees are chaired by the opposition, so we'll size up the Tory hopefuls, too.)

PUBLIC SAFETY — One House committee did elect its chair Wednesday. The public safety committee will be helmed by JIM CARR, the former natural resources minister who later served as a "special representative" for the Prairies in Cabinet.

Carr was dropped from the ministry in October, but now he gets his consolation prize — and the PMO has a friendly face on another committee. "Maybe more important than anything else, I hope to be efficient," Carr joked in opening remarks. "So let's be efficient together, with a spirit of camaraderie.

— The rest of the squad: The other Liberals on the public safety committee are parliamentary secretary PAM DAMOFF, former health committee chair RON MCKINNON, PAUL CHIANG, TALEEB NOORMOHAMED and SAMEER ZUBERI. Tories are vice-chair RAQUEL DANCHO, DANE LLOYD, DOUG SHIPLEY and TAKO VAN POPTA. The Bloc's rep is second vice-chair KRISTINA MICHAUD. And ALISTAIR MACGREGOR is holding down the fort for the New Democrats.

HOUSE BUSINESS

AFGHANISTAN — The Commons also has its first special committee of the session. Only the Liberals opposed the Tory motion that will task MPs with an extensive analysis of the government's response to the collapse of Afghanistan's government — and the chaotic humanitarian crisis that followed.

TIME'S RUNNING OUT — Government House Leader MARK HOLLAND moved a time allocation motion on Bill C-3, which would restrict debate on the sickleave and health worker-protection bill to no more than one sitting day. The Tories and Bloc resented any Liberal attempt to thwart debate on the bill. As the Commons argued about that, Justice Minister DAVID LAMETTI was defending the legislation at a Senate committee. (The NDP teamed up with the Liberals to limit debate on C-3.)

LAB DOCS SPAT — Tory House leader GERARD DELTELL formally responded to Holland's latest proposal on how MPs can examine — without endangering national security — hundreds of documents related to the dismissal of two scientists from Winnipeg's National Microbiology Laboratory.

In short, Holland's gambit failed. He had pitched the same arrangement as a similar special committee in the Harper era that analyzed documents related to the Afghan detainee scandal. Deltell said Holland was comparing "apples and oranges."

— In case there was any doubt: Wednesday's proceedings on Afghanistan, C-3 and the lab docs reminded all and sundry that last week's lovey-dovey spirit of cooperation was the exception, not the rule, as MPs race toward Christmas.

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS

— Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU will be in Toronto tonight for a fundraiser at the Brickworks Ciderhouse on gentrifying Queen Street East. Reporters will cover his opening remarks.

— The Assembly of First Nations' special chiefs assembly convenes at 11 a.m. in Ottawa.

— Auditor General KAREN HOGAN drops four reports, which will be tabled in the Commons at 2 p.m.-ish. These ones are biggies: protecting Canada's food system; the health and safety of temporary foreign workers in the Covid era; the regional relief and recovery fund; and enforcement of Covid quarantine and testing orders.

— Parliamentary Budget Officer YVES GIROUX will release a report on family wealth distribution in Canada and a legislative costing note on the federal wage subsidy. The PBO will also appear at a Senate committee where the order of the day is the government's supplementary estimates. (Senators will hear today from a whopping 28 witnesses over five hours.)

— Privacy Commissioner DANIEL THERRIEN will release his final annual report as his 10-year term starts to wind down. He will take questions from reporters at 11:30 ET.

— Women and Gender Equality Minister MARCI IEN and Indigenous Services Minister PATTY HAJDU will join a panel discussion on community leaders' vision to address violence against missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQQIA+ individuals.

ASK US ANYTHING

What are you hearing that you need Playbook to know? Send it all our way.

PROZONE

Pro s should not miss the Pro Canada PM memo from ZI-ANN LUM and ANDY BLATCHFORD: Freeland vs. Poilievre at FINA.

In other news from Lum: P.E.I. potato board warns U.S. trade freeze could destroy truckloads of spuds.

In more headlines for s:
House overwhelmingly passes Uyghur Act, setting up talks with Senate.
Bank of Canada maintains interest rate amid red-hot inflation.
What you need to know about COP26 climate deals.
White House to rally countries against gender-based online harassment.
Biden order requires net-zero federal government emissions by 2050.
EU Green Deal chief: West must resist ‘the dark side.’

MEDIA ROOM

— Foreign Minister MÉLANIE JOLY told CBC's Power & Politics that she spent time Wednesday with MICHAEL KOVRIG and MICHAEL SPAVOR . Joly said the feds are still working to resolve remaining legal issues — including the not-so-minor fact that the Chinese still claim to have released the Two Michaels on bail.

— Top of POLITICO this morning: Old foes thwart Biden’s foreign policy pivot.

— Questions from AARON WHERRY: “Is there anything particularly magical about the current voting age of 18? If not, why couldn't we lower it to something like 16?”

— From The Globe's GEOFFREY YORK and MARIEKE WALSH: Canada faces growing global criticism of its African travel bans.

DAVID CYMBALUK, a farmer and blogger in Alberta, writes that tensions within JASON KENNEY's United Conservatives shouldn't surprise anybody. Kenney's party was, after all, a merger of two rather distinct right-leaning factions.

— Canada's federal access-to-information regime is “a broken system rife with practical and ideological hurdles,” write MARGARET THOMPSON, ELYSE AMEND and LUISA MARINI.

— The Star's RAISA PATEL writes: The U.S. ranks travel destinations by their COVID-19 risk. Why doesn’t Canada do the same?

— The Hill Times looks at the next Canada-U.S. trade beef. (Which is beef.)

PLAYBOOKERS

Birthdays: HBD to Liberal Research Bureau managing director MELISSA COTTON … and former Quebec Liberal MNA DIANE LEBLANC.

Spotted: Governor General MARY SIMON granting royal assent for the first time.

Ukraine, officially entering the gallows humor phase of a potential military showdown with Russia.… Canada's man at the UN, BOB RAE, subtweeting the Ontario government (background here).… P.E.I. Premier DENNIS KING, advocating on the Hill for “the best dog gone potatoes that's ever been growed”.… JASON KENNEY, declaring Alberta the "most Canadian province."

From the ethics files: Playbook's stroll through MP disclosures landed at the summary for Natural Resources Minister JONATHAN WILKINSON, who reported common shares of Amazon, Bell, Enbridge, Invesco, Pfizer, 3M, TD Bank and Royal Dutch Shell. Okay then.

New lobbyists: Cumberland Strategies senior consultant DEREK LIPMAN is repping Midori-Bio, a green-tech manufacturer of a chemical that dramatically speeds up plastic biodegradability. The company is sniffing around for details on the government's plastics ban. Midori-Bio's VP of comms and business development is BEN MULRONEY.

— Clean coal? Lipman also signed up with Consuma Resources, a "leading Canadian producer and exporter of premium steelmaking coal." The company wants to "make representations to the federal government regarding the Large Employer Emergency Financing Facility and the Business Credit Availability Program to ensure the company's stability during the COVID-19 pandemic."

Pro s will recall that LEEFF recipients "must agree to publish annual climate-related financial disclosures that will include how they plan to help Canada reach its climate goals."

Movers and shakers: The co-winners of the 2021 National Business Book Award are STEPHEN R. BOWN (The Company: The Rise and Fall of the Hudson’s Bay Empire) and MARK CARNEY (Value(s): Building A Better World for All).

Media mentions: XTRA MAGAZINE is welcoming back its comments section, seven years after shutting it down.

THE CANADIAN ASSOCIATION OF BLACK JOURNALISTS is inviting applications for CABJ Media Startup Bootcamp grants.… The CANADIAN ASSOCIATION OF JOURNALISTS annual awards are open for submissions.

TRIVIA

SAVE THE DATE: TRIVIA — Don't make plans for Dec. 21 at 7 p.m. ET. Playbook is whipping up our first-ever virtual trivia night with Outside The Box Trivia. It will be a chance to show off your knowledge of #cdnpoli. RSVP with your team details to Ottawa Playbook. Registration is free. We’ll send sign up details. The trivia platform enables you to gather teammates from all over — you can play and collaborate at the same virtual table, as long as you all have access to WiFi.

Wednesday’s answer: GURBAX SINGH MALHI was first elected in 1993. “When I ran for the first time, I was told I wouldn’t win for another 50 years because of the turban,” he said. He would be the first MP to wear one in the House and went on to serve as an MP for 18 years.

Props to STACEY NORONHA, WALTER ROBINSON, GEORGE YOUNG, SHEILA GERVAIS, ALAN KAN, MICHAEL MACDONALD, BOOTS VAISEY, LEIGH LAMPERT, BRAM ABRAMSON and GOZDE KAZAZOGLU.

Thursday’s question: Who did Nickelback’s CHAD KROEGER visit at 24 Sussex?

Send your answers to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

Have a petition you want signed? A cause you’re promoting? Seeking to increase brand awareness amongst this key audience? Share your message with our influential readers to foster engagement and drive action. Contact Alejandra Waase to find out how: awaase@politico.com.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Andy Blatchford @AndyBlatchford

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Dec 08,2021 11:01 am - Wednesday

A week of surprises in Ottawa

Dec 07,2021 11:01 am - Tuesday

On the first day of FINA

Dec 03,2021 11:02 am - Friday

Putting the fun in dysfunction

Dec 02,2021 11:02 am - Thursday

Spotted: Celebration in the House

Dec 01,2021 11:02 am - Wednesday

Covid and political fatigue 5.0

Nov 30,2021 11:03 am - Tuesday

An orderly shakeup in the Senate