Slouching towards freedom

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Wednesday Feb 09,2022 11:03 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Feb 09, 2022 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Zi-Ann Lum

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Zi-Ann l Follow Politico Canada

WELCOME TO OTTAWA PLAYBOOK. I’m your host, ZI-ANN LUM. We follow the ripples of a rare rebuke on the Hill à la JOËL LIGHTBOUND and consider if his words will augur nuanced discussions about Covid-19 and polarization — or entrench it deeper in political discourse. A new POLITICO Morning Consult Global Sustainability Poll compares attitudes across 13 countries. Plus, DAVID NAYLOR offers a level set on luck and pandemic leadership.

Driving the Day

COURAGE AND CAUCUS — Both Covid-19 and the convoy have been force multipliers in Ottawa.

Conservative caucus meets today, a week after MPs showed some political aikido, using momentum from the Freedom Convoy to push out ERIN O’TOOLE . The palpable frustration inside and outside Parliament Hill for nearly two weeks has not only transformed the Tories, it has also catalyzed internal Liberal discord out for display.

Just look at Liberal JOËL LIGHTBOUND’s career progression into a maverick MP.

Lightbound stunned Ottawa with his decision to publicly break rank with his government’s Covid-19 positioning. Quite a birthday to remember for the Quebec MP.

— The cause: “Both the tone and the policies of my government changed drastically on the eve and during the last election campaign,” Lightbound told reporters Tuesday. "A decision was made to wedge, to divide and to stigmatize. I fear that this politicization of the pandemic risks undermining the public's trust in our public health institutions.”

He said he made his views known in caucus many times — and isn’t the only one who feels a similar way. “There are multiple colleagues that are uncomfortable with the type of politics that we have on this pandemic,” he said, without offering names.

— The consequence: Lightbound resigned as chair of the Quebec Liberal caucus. But despite his decision to go rogue, the Louis-Hébert MP hasn’t been thrown out of his party.

Liberal whip STEVEN MACKINNON said in a statement : “He has expressed clear confidence in the government, and remains a member of Liberal caucus.” It’s a precedent set under unprecedented circumstances.

Whether more Liberals follow Lightbound’s lead remains to be seen.

— The effect: Lightbound’s confession found him praise on the other side of the aisle. Conservative MP GARNETT GENUIS applauded his colleague’s courage, which he called contagious. “ It's time for more MPs to speak out for unity, common sense, and hope,” Genius said.

Former N.B. Liberal Party leader KEVIN VICKERS saluted Lightbound for doing a fine job.

JANE PHILPOTT added her two cents, pulling notes from the day she and JODY WILSON-RAYBOULD were turfed from Liberal caucus. She tweeted : “Thoughts from a speech I wrote for caucus but was not able to deliver, April 2, 2019: It is healthy for democracy if MPs respectfully express different opinions. A party should be a safe place for MPs with dissenting views. MPs needn't agree with every decision of the government.”

Liberal MP NATE-ERSKINE SMITH disagreed with presumptions that Lightbound’s career has flatlined. “ I don’t think his political career is over ,” he tweeted. “We don’t need to agree on all issues, and some of what he’s articulated (the need to re-evaluate measures as we go on) has been reiterated by Dr. Tam.”

Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister MARC MILLER told reporters he has some problems with Lightbound’s decision to make his grievances public, suggesting political debate is muddying the primary objective, which is saving lives.

“It’s something we’ve been relentless in doing over the last two years and if Canadians think that’s politicizing the debate, I think they need to screw their heads on better," Miller said.

POLITICO’s ANDY BLATCHFORD has more on Lightbound’s break from the centre — and a report on the latest from Ottawa police.

Hear Andy talk about the occupation on POLITICO’s Dispatch.

DISPATCH FROM THE GROUND — Ottawa’s deputy police chief STEVE BELL told reporters Tuesday that officers have arrested 22 people, handed out more than 1,300 tickets and have 79 active criminal investigations.

Police have also discovered that children live in approximately 100 of the 419 trucks “encamped” in the city. Authorities worry the kids could be at risk in any police operation. Bell said the force is working with the Children’s Aid Society to ensure they’re safe.

“It's something that greatly concerns us,” said Bell, who listed risks such as noise levels from the protest, carbon monoxide from the truck fumes, the cold temperatures and access to sanitation, like a shower.

Bell also said his officers worked with U.S. law enforcement to make an arrest in Ohio after an individual in the state allegedly called in fake threats designed to deceive and distract emergency resources in Ottawa.

Morale, he said, has taken a hit as the police force awaits possible reinforcements from the provincial and federal governments.

“Our members are tired,” he said. “They go out every single day down to our downtown core to try and take back a portion of our city that's been lost to this occupation. They work extremely hard in cold weather and extremely difficult conditions.”

CONVOY CONVERT — POLITICO’s KELLY HOOPER bumped into Sen. TED CRUZ (R-Texas) on Capitol Hill and asked him for his thoughts on Canada’s so-called Freedom Convoy.The Texas Republican said Tuesday he would welcome an expansion of the protests into the U.S.

“The Canadian trucker protest is a remarkable uprising and it's a manifestation of the deep outrage across Canada and across the United States, directed at petty authoritarian government leaders who are trying to force vaccines onto unwilling people,” he said.

In related news Tuesday, POLITICO’s ALEX DAUGHERTY reports on the shut down at the the busiest U.S.-Canada border crossing.

GLOBAL CLIMATE POLITICS — A new POLITICO Morning Consult Global Sustainability Poll reveals frustration from citizens that they are being left to take on climate action on their own, when they believe governments and the companies with the most resources (which also tend to bear the most responsibility for carbon emissions) should shoulder the burden.

POLITICO’s RYAN HEALTH reports: “The United States is home to the largest ideological divide on climate action. Among Americans, 97 percent of left-leaning voters expressed concern about climate change, compared to 51 percent of right-leaning voters.”

In Canada, results suggest a majority of left-leaning Green, NDP and Liberal Party supporters consider climate change an issue of top concern — while one in five federal Conservative supporters and nearly half of People's Party supporters say they aren’t concerned at all.

Greens most concerned about climate change in Canada


MORE ON CLIMATE — Health Canada is set to publish “Health of Canadians in a Changing Climate: Advancing our Knowledge for Action” today. The report, which was planned for release last fall, examines the impact of climate change on Canada’s health care system with a review of food and water security issues, air quality and infectious disease.

A ‘FRESH TAKE’ REPORT — The Canadian Institute for Climate Choices releases a new paper today called “Cutting to the Chase on Fossil Fuel Subsidies.” The paper departs from using unclear “competing definitions and estimates of fossil fuel subsidies,” Climate Choice’s clean growth research director RACHEL SAMSON told reporters during a briefing.

Its four recommendations for the government includes a nudge to get recently launched measures, such as the proposed federal carbon capture, utilization and storage investment tax credit, right. The second priority should be to tackle measures hindering the energy transition, it says.

FOMO — Alberta has started to ease Covid-19 restrictions, joining Saskatchewan and Quebec in changing rules as hospitalization rates drop.

Premier JASON KENNEY called it a “path back to normal.”

The province’s Health Minister JASON COPPING said the changes reflect steps to “learn to live with Covid,” a phrase being repeated by more politicians despite it not meaning anything new after two years of living with the virus, adapting lifestyles to limiting the potential toll of the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

HALLWAY CONVERSATION

What basics of pandemic public health risk being lost as politicians press for the lifting of Covid-19 restrictions/vaccine mandates?

David Naylor, COVID-19 Immunity Task Force co-chair : Some premiers will stand down these maddening mandates and restrictions carefully while tracking various measures to ensure that their provincial Omicron wave keeps receding. That makes very good sense.

Others, alas, will act rapidly based on political considerations, and hope they get lucky.

I also hope they get lucky, but hope is not a strategy, and people are not poker chips to be played in political games of chance with a virus that has already killed tens of thousands of Canadians.

ASK US ANYTHING

What are you hearing that you need Playbook to know? Send it all our way.

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS

10 a.m. Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU will attend Liberal caucus. In the afternoon, he will participate in question period at 2 p.m.

9:30 a.m. Statistics Canada officials will hold a press conference to go over the first results from the 2021 Census, which will focus on Canada’s growing population, dwelling counts and international and domestic migration patterns.

12 p.m. Bank of Canada Governor TIFF MACKLEM is on deck for a fireside chat at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce’s annual Canada 360° Economic Summit.

Innovation, Science and Industry Minister FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE has his own fireside chat scheduled for 4:25 p.m.

3:30 p.m. National Defence Minister ANITA ANAND appears before the House national defence committee for a briefing about her mandate letter.

3:30 p.m. Environment Minister STEVEN GUILBEALT will hold a press conference to re-introduce a bill to “strengthen protections for Canadians health and the environment.”

3:30 p.m. Official Languages Commissioner RAYMOND THÉBERGE briefs MPs on the official languages committee on urgent issues related to the Official Languages Act.

3:30 p.m. Shell Canada President and Country Chair SUSANNAH PIERCE answers questions from the House’s natural resource committee in its study of an oil and gas sector emissions cap.

4:15 p.m. Sen. JULIE MIVILLE-DECHÊNE will field questions in the Senate’s legal and constitutional affairs committee about her private members’ bill seeking to restrict young people’s online access to pornography . Law professor MICHAEL GEIST will also appear as a witness before the Senate committee.

OFFICIAL BUSINESS

4 p.m. The Senate Standing Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology meet to discuss Bill S-209, An Act respecting Pandemic Observance Day.

6:30 p.m. The Senate Standing Committee on Banking, Trade and Commerce and The Senate Standing Committee on Transport and Communications will each meet in camera.

MEDIA ROOM

— CP's BILL GRAVELAND reports that Alberta border protesters are planning to stay for the long haul.

— "I told y’all," ERICA IFILL writes in The Hill Times. "And now we’re an international embarrassment."

— In Foreign Affairs, ORVILLE SCHELL writes about XI JINPING’s big Olympics spectacle and what it reveals about China — and its growing list of critics and opponents.

— Social media columnist ARWA MAHDAWI is in The Guardian with an argument about why the world should be paying attention to the “baddies” in Ottawa: “It’s an astroturfed movement — one that creates an impression of widespread grassroots support where little exists — funded by a global network of highly organised far-right groups and amplified by Facebook’s misinformation machine.”

— For The Line, JEN GERSON reads the room and points to a mandates backlash and “ the inevitable drama that the coming populist wave will entail.”

— Maclean’s PAUL WELLS writes about being “torn” on JOËL LIGHTBOUND. “ It’s funny how the nines and 10s are so often the ones to snap around here,” writes Wells.

PROZONE

If you’re a POLITICO Pro , don’t miss the latest edition of our afternoon policy newsletter: Covid response fuels blockades and dissent.

In other headlines for Pros:
Canadian truckers shut down the busiest U.S.-Canada border crossing.
Why Germany pipes down when talk turns to Nord Stream 2 sanctions.
U.S. Army sets 2050 net-zero emissions goal.
Town challenges status of congressional candidate's home as a tax-free parsonage.
America's Bitcoin miners see Ga. as new U.S. hot spot.

THE BUZZ


Birthdays: A belated HBD to Liberal MP JENNA SUDDS, who celebrated yesterday.

Spotted: SULLY SULLENBERGER adjusting to a new life in Montreal “ one layer at a time” … High Commissioner RALPH GOODALE sitting down with Saskatchewan legend HEATHER SALLOUM, private secretary to 5 of the province’s lieutenant governorsPIERRE POILIEVRE, but LEGOWHIT FRASER, self-isolating with Covid-19.

Movers and shakers: The Business Council of Canada has a new chair: CIBC President and CEO VICTOR DODIG … Proof Strategies’ CHRIS MCCLUSKEY is now senior director of government relations and MAURICE RIOUX has been promoted to director of government relations.

Media mentions: TEMUR DURRANI has officially joined the Globe as a tech reporter … CNN’s DANIEL DALE, with a never-meet-your-heroes lesson, after an exchange with retired hockey player THEO FLEURY … Journalist AARON ORLANDO giving a +1 to the B.C. government “winning” the provincial category of the CAJ’s Cone of Silence award.

TRIVIA

Tuesday’s answer: Saskatchewan Minister of Government Relations DON MCMORRIS is proud dad to snowboarding legend MARK MCMORRIS, who won a bronze medal this week in men’s slopestyle. Watch the family watch his run here.

Props to LYNN MYERS, SHANE O’NEILL, ROBERT MCDOUGALL and GOZDE KAZAZOGLU.

Wednesday’s question: Ontario Premier DOUG FORD changed the slogan on Ontario’s personal licence plates to say A PLACE TO GROW. What did those words replace?

Send your answers to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Andy Blatchford @AndyBlatchford

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Feb 08,2022 11:02 am - Tuesday

Everybody’s tired

Feb 07,2022 11:03 am - Monday

How Ottawa’s convoy went viral

Feb 04,2022 11:02 am - Friday

Here's an idea: Ban the swastika

Feb 03,2022 11:01 am - Thursday

It's Candice Bergen's party for now

Feb 02,2022 11:01 am - Wednesday

Erin O’Toole: Over and out?

Feb 01,2022 11:01 am - Tuesday

Erin O'Toole vs. everybody

Jan 31,2022 11:01 am - Monday

Running on empty