The new 'ethical oil' debate

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Tuesday Mar 01,2022 11:01 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Mar 01, 2022 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Nick Taylor-Vaisey and Zi-Ann Lum

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Nick | Follow Politico Canada

WELCOME TO OTTAWA PLAYBOOK. I'm your host, Nick Taylor-Vaisey with Zi-Ann Lum. Today is the sixth day of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, with reports of an armored convoy stretching 65 kilometers advancing on Kyiv. Here at home, a certain Tory leadership contender is going all-in on Canadian energy as a key piece of western resistance to VLADIMIR PUTIN . Also, POLITICO follows the story of an Afghan refugee family that dreams of Canada — but is stuck in Ukraine.

Driving the Day

CANADA'S NEXT ENERGY DEBATE — Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU and his ministers announced lethal aid to Ukraine on Monday in the form of anti-tank weaponry and rockets. Immigration Minister SEAN FRASER unveiled a suite of measures aimed at making it easier for Ukrainians to stay in or get to Canada (though he stopped short of dropping visa requirements).

The PM also declared a ban on Russian oil imports. (POLITICO's ZI-ANN LUM confirms: Canada doesn't import any oil from Russia.)

But it wasn't an oil ban that riled up a leading Tory on Monday. The leading candidate for the party's permanent leadership, PIERRE POILIEVRE, zeroed in on Canada's inability to export vast reserves of oil and gas that could help Europe shake its addiction to Russian energy.

— The 'world's cleanest' energy: Poilievre followed up a National Post op-ed with a slick video on how Canada should face off against Russian aggression.

Here's the elevator pitch:

"As always, petroleum is driving geopolitics. Europe has to beg Putin for energy, so Putin holds all the cards. But we can help take away those cards, because Canada has what Europe needs, and lots of it: energy."

— "My government will": Poilievre's six-minute vid is as bold as ever. Skipping past the leadership race, Carleton's MP argues from the front benches. “As prime minister,” he says, “I will scrap Trudeau's anti-energy laws.” (That's C-69 and C-48, which beef up rules around pipeline approvals and maritime crude transport.)

What would replace those laws? Better ones, he says, that consult First Nations and produce quick decisions. (He offers no specifics.) Poilievre would also fast-track energy projects — say, LNG terminals — that could export Canadian energy to international markets. (Again, no specifics.)

— Reality check: While replacing Europe’s reliance on Russian natural gas with a Canadian supply makes for a compelling political argument, it glosses over the realities of building resource projects in this country. Spoiler alert: It takes a long time. The only liquefied natural gas terminal in Atlantic Canada is in Saint John, N.B. — and it's an import facility. LNG Canada’s Kitimat, B.C. export facility, Canada’s first, is 50 percent complete.

— The view from Alberta: Premier JASON KENNEY was singing from the same songbook as Poilievre: "Message to Ottawa and Washington: stop helping Putin and OPEC by killing pipelines"

QUOTE OF THE DAY: Deputy PM CHRYSTIA FREELAND set the stakes for Ukraine's defense of its capital city under siege — a pivotal moment with few parallels that deserves the world's full attention.

"There are moments in history when the great struggle between freedom and tyranny comes down to one fight in one place which is waged for all of humanity. In 1863 that place was Gettysburg. In 1940 it was the skies above Britain. Today in 2022 it is Kyiv."

— Honorable mention: Canada's man at the U.N., BOB RAE, delivered his second rebuke of Putin's invasion in a week: "We don’t go to war," he told an emergency session of the General Assembly. "We go to the negotiating table. We go to court. We go to mediators. That is how we resolve disputes. The other way lies madness."

Read the full transcript here.

— From POLITICO: International Criminal Court to open probe.

HUMANITARIAN CRISIS — FILIPPO GRANDI didn't mince words at the U.N. Security Council on Monday. The U.N. high commissioner for refugees painted a stark crisis of the mass westward migration away from hostilities in Ukraine:

"As we speak, there are 520,000 refugees from Ukraine in neighboring countries. This figure has been rising exponentially, hour after hour, literally, since Thursday. I have worked in refugee crises for almost 40 years and I have rarely seen such an incredibly fast-rising exodus of people — the largest, surely, within Europe, since the Balkan wars."

— From POLITICO: Russian escalation in Ukraine could lead to humanitarian crisis.

Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, Romania and Moldova are all throwing their doors open to Ukrainians fleeing their homeland.

But not everyone is so lucky. A desperate family of Afghan refugees who dream of a new life in Canada can't find their way out of Ukraine. The Safis were twice turned away from Slovakia last week. They took a train to the Polish border, where they were again deemed ineligible by border guards.

— From Kabul to Kyiv: Mir Safi was a prosecutor in the Attorney General's Office of Afghanistan before Kabul fell last August. The 47-year-old managed to escape with his family on a flight to Kyiv, where they hoped to sort out the paperwork required to get to Canada and claim asylum.

A special immigration program for human-rights defenders seemed tailor-made for people like Mir, who'd put Talib criminals in jail.

But they made little headway with the Canadian bureaucracy. They lived for several months in a UN Refugee Agency-operated facility in western Ukraine. When VLADIMIR PUTIN's forces invaded to the east, the Safis knew they couldn't stay put.

Now they're on the move, desperate for a lucky break but not sure how they'll find one. Read your Playbook host's full story here.

— Chalk it up to racism: The Safis' experience isn't unique. The Globe's PAUL WALDIE and GEOFFREY YORK chronicle the racial discrimination faced by African and Asian refugees at the Polish border.

One account from a woman in Przemysl: “To be honest, there was a lot of racism. Because the Ukrainians always came first, even though we Africans would be there for days and sometimes three days with no food. Everyone was just exhausted. Any time Ukrainians came, they told us to go back. They were shouting at us, ‘go back.’ It was really crazy.”

— From POLITICO: JOSH POSANER sent this video dispatch from Lviv in western Ukraine which is a key staging post for refugees en route out of the country.

AROUND THE HILL

SENATE REFORM, NATCH — Sen. COLIN DEACON is aiming to introduce a motion as early as today to motivate senators to show climate leadership by establishing a new environmental and sustainability policy for how public funds are spent.

Deacon tells Playbook he’s optimistic the motion will be adopted because the upper chamber’s climate credibility is on the line.

“The Senate's role as being responsible for vulnerable and less heard voices has a responsibility to show leadership on this issue because it is so difficult, clearly, to make progress,” Deacon said, calling from Ottawa.

“And if we don't actually make progress as an institution, how do we hold the government to account, which is our responsibility?”

— From the motion: The policy statement, if adopted, would replace the Senate’s environmental policy ratified in 1993. The new statement has already been adopted by the Senate’s powerful internal economy, budgets and administration committee.

Its text is written to incentivize the chamber of sober second thought to shrink its carbon footprint. How? By embracing climate-friendly transportation rules, updating procurement criteria, going digital-first to minimize printing and waste — and establishing “support from central agencies to allow the Senate to charge carbon offsets” to move the institution toward more sustainable operations.

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS

U.S. President JOE BIDEN delivers his first State of the Union address tonight. POLITICO has you covered. Here's a pair of pre-game primers:

State of the Union 2022: What to know ahead of Biden's speech
Video: Six things to know about State of the Union 2022

9 a.m. The Parliamentary Budget Officer will post a new report: “Economic and Fiscal Outlook – March 2022.”

9:30 a.m. Bloc Québécois leader YVES-FRANÇOIS BLANCHET will hold a press conference in advance of his party's opposition motion in the House.

11 a.m. Green leader AMITA KUTTNER will join MPs ELIZABETH MAY and MIKE MORRICE to talk about the latest report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

12 p.m. Official Languages Minister GINETTE PETITPAS TAYLOR will be in Grand-Pré, N.S., for a press conference on a new bill to revamp federal language laws.

12:30 p.m. JAGMEET SINGH meets with the Canadian Home Builders’ Association.

4 p.m. Trade Minister MARY NG will deliver remarks and moderate a BMO panel: “Women Business Owners: Advancing Sustainability.” Panelists include senior VP SHERI GRIFFITHS and SHARON HAWARD-LAIRD, the bank's executive sponsor for women and sustainability.

In other U.S. news today, the 2022 midterm elections officially kick off in Texas. The Democratic primaries will be a test of progressive strength. Here are 6 House races to watch.

ALSO FOR YOUR RADAR

— March 9: That's when the 90th annual Ottawa Conference on Security & Defense launches at the Chateau Laurier. Featured speakers include Defense Minister ANITA ANAND, Chief of the Defense Staff Gen. WAYNE EYRE, NATO secretary-general JENS STOLTENBERG, leader of Democratic Belarus SVIATLANA TSIKHANOUSKAYA, Japanese Gen. YAMAZAKI KOJI, and U.K. vice-chief of the defense staff Adm. Sir TIM FRASER.

ASK US ANYTHING

TELL US WHAT YOU KNOW — What are you hearing that you need Playbook to know? Send it all our way.

PAPER TRAIL

TALE OF A TRANSITION — To no one's surprise, the briefing binder presented to Health Minister JEAN-YVES DUCLOS when he got the job last October spanned more than 500 pages.

The crash course in bureaucratese, obtained by POLITICO via access-to-information request, covers every department and agency in Duclos' bailiwick — a complex dossier in normal times, a hefty tome in the middle of a pandemic.

— "D" and "E": Two sections of a primer on the "First 100 days" are redacted entirely. The documents cite the section of the information law that protects solicitor-client privilege. What quagmires lie hidden behind the censorship?

MEDIA ROOM

Monday’s POLITICO’s West Wing Playbook is a must-read for those who keep up with USTR KATHERINE TAI.

From the FINANCIAL POST: How the Russia-Ukraine crisis is impacting markets, business and the economy.

— EDWARD BURTYNSKY writes in Maclean’s: What it takes to truly fight for freedom in Ukraine (with references to the perogies and cabbage rolls of St. Catharines).

— MP GREG FERGUS appears on the Bad + Bitchy podcast in conversation with ERICA IFILL. 

— The National Post's CATHERINE LÉVESQUE scooped the news that probably Conservative leadership candidate JEAN CHAREST will be in Ottawa for an informal Wednesday evening grip-and-grin with Tory MPs.

— Global sleuths SAM COOPER and ANDREW RUSSELL uncover over C$154 million in GTA real estate investments tied to XIAO JIANHUA, a detained Chinese-Canadian oligarch.

PLAYBOOKERS

Birthdays: HBD to New Brunswick Premier BLAINE HIGGS; MONIQUE BÉGIN, feminist trailblazer; and former Liberal MP MARLENE CATTERALL.

More birthday greetings for former data journalist and current federal public servant WILLIAM WOLFE-WYLIE.

HBD +1 to National Post comment editor CARSON JEREMA — and to HADRIEN TRUDEAU!

HBD + 3 to investigative journalist-turned-climate reporting prof SEAN HOLMAN.

From the tenders: The feds are buying up more and more flu vaccine doses. … The Department of National Defense paid General Dynamics C$4.8 million for 4,968 landmines — C$946.28 a pop. A spokesperson told Playbook they'll be used for training purposes.

Spotted: International Trade Minister MARY NG starting her day in Washington D.C. with Sen. CHUCK GRASSLEY (R-Iowa).

Canada Soccer, now refusing to play Russian teams — and Canada's ambassador to Ukraine, LARISA GALADZA, giving the association a break for taking a few days to come to that decision: "They are a bunch of soccer people, not a foreign ministry. No one should worry about whether it is too late to do the thing you can do."

An anonymous bureaucrat at National Defense, editing the Wikipedia page of the manufacturer of anti-tank weaponry that Canada is exporting to Ukraine.

Tory MP ADAM CHAMBERS, trying and failing to get the Liberals to commit to a temporary two-year ban on foreign purchases of Canadian residential properties.

StrategyCorp's GARRY KELLER, spying former Canadian ambo to Russia CHRIS WESTDAL's quiet resignation from the board of a mining company with operations in Russia.

Alberta NDP MLA SHANNON PHILLIPS, on a list of critics assembled by the Edmonton Police Association.

Movers and shakers: Diplomat ALEX BUGAILISKIS has retired after four decades in public service. “Diplomacy is more important than ever,” she noted in a Twitter thread. She joined the then-Department of External Affairs in 1982.

“You have been a mentor and an inspiration to me,” tweeted LOUISE BLAIS. “Your brand of diplomacy has been so effective across the span of your stellar career.”

LIVIA BELCEA, a former staffer for MARC GARNEAU and JIM WATSON, is starting a new gig at Edelman as a senior account manager in Montreal.

RANDALL BARTLETT joins the Desjardins Group as a senior director of Canadian economics.

The newspaper Le Devoir popped up in the lobbyist registry after a meeting on taxation policy with Heritage Minister PABLO RODRIGUEZ, senior policy adviser BRIAN MACKAY and senior adviser SIMON ROSS.

The Canadian Home Builders' Association met with Liberal MP JULIE DZEROWICZ , a member of the Commons finance committee, and Tory housing critic MATT JENEROUX.

Media mentions: The Canadian Association of Journalists has just released its roster of mentors for Winter 2022.

Playbook’s ZI-ANN LUM is on the list, which includes AMANDA FOLLETT HOSGOOD, ANNA MARIA TREMONTI, BHUPINDER HUNDAL, CARLOS OSORIO, EVAN SOLOMON, KAREN HO, KARON LIU, LINDSEY WIEBE, MAUREEN HALUSHAK, MURAD HEMMADI, PAUL WELLS and TAHIERÒN:IOHTE DAN DAVID. Application deadline is March 18.

Ryerson's School of Journalism has a new chair: RAVI MOHABEER.

Anniversaries: NDP MP CHARLIE ANGUS honored SHANNEN KOOSTACHIN in the House on Monday. “Ten years ago, the Parliament of Canada came together in an extraordinary motion of solidarity by unanimously passing Shannen's dream to end the systemic underfunding of First Nation education,” he said.

“At the age of 13, she stood up to the brutal conditions in her home community of Attawapiskat First Nation and launched the largest youth-driven children's rights movement in Canadian history, forever changing the discussion about Indigenous rights in Canada.” Koostachin was killed in a highway accident in 2010. In 2020, CBC News wrote on her legacy.

Farewells: Covid-19 health measures and restrictions have ended in Saskatchewan.

Here’s CAROL OFF’s farewell to As It Happens. "Pass the Kleenex.”

PROZONE

In news for POLITICO Pro s:

Landmark climate report details 'an atlas of human suffering.’
The link between Putin and climate change.
Canada to ban all Russian crude oil imports.
Hospitals, health care organizations brace for Russian cyber threat.
Twitter to label all state-affiliated Russia media.

The latest edition of the POLITICO Pro Canada PM newsletter is here.

HOUSE BUSINESS

11 a.m. The fisheries and oceans committee will study the traceability of fish and seafood products.

11 a.m.The environment committee will hear from Atomic Energy of Canada Limited, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories and Hydro-Québec as it considers nuclear waste governance.

11 a.m. The citizenship and immigration committee hears from final witnesses in its study of recruitment and acceptance rates of foreign students.

11 a.m. The public accounts committee will hear from the Auditor General’s Office on departments and agencies on the AG’s report on protecting Canada’s food system.

3:30 p.m. The industry committee will meet behind closed doors to consider its draft report on critical minerals.

3:30 p.m. Treasury Board President MONA FORTIER and senior officials will be at the government operations committee.

3:30 p.m. The human rights committee will hear from witnesses as it reviews the Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act.

3:30 p.m. The status of women committee continues its study of intimate partner and domestic violence.

6:30 p.m.The veterans affairs committee will hear from the Royal Canadian Legion on the desecration of monuments honoring veterans.

… and in the Senate:

9 a.m. The fisheries and oceans committee will hear from fisheries officials as it studies Indigenous rights-based fisheries.

11 a.m.The rules and procedure committee meets with the agenda to come.

5 p.m.The ethics committee will hear from PIERRE LEGAULT and DEBORAH PALUMBO as it considers the Ethics and Conflict of Interest Code for Senators.

TRIVIA

Monday's answer: The Rideau Canal Skateway first opened during the 1970-1971 season. NCC chair DOUG FULLERTON came up with the idea.

Props to BOB PLAMONDON, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, PATRICK HART, LEIGH LAMPERT and BOB GORDON. 

Tuesday’s question: Who said: “One very, very important topic and a major topic in feminism today is all forms of violence to women. It was never mentioned in our public hearings. We didn't even have a chapter on that in the report because then it was considered part of private life. That is the biggest change in feminism of today compared to the time of the royal commission.”

Send your answers to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Andy Blatchford @AndyBlatchford

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Feb 28,2022 11:00 am - Monday

The month that lasted a year

Feb 24,2022 11:02 am - Thursday

Blasts from Kharkiv to Kyiv

Feb 23,2022 11:03 am - Wednesday

The Peace Tower’s last song

Feb 22,2022 11:02 am - Tuesday

An anticlimactic vote of historic proportions

Feb 21,2022 11:06 am - Monday

Dialed up to 11

Feb 18,2022 11:04 am - Friday

Advice for the interregnum