Mayor Brown’s path to victory

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Monday Mar 14,2022 10:01 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Mar 14, 2022 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Nick Taylor-Vaisey

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Nick | Follow Politico Canada

Welcome to Ottawa Playbook. I'm your host, Nick Taylor-Vaisey. Today is Monday, and PATRICK BROWN is hoping to style himself a comeback kid. We asked a Liberal MP to remember what it was like the first week Covid shut down Ottawa. And a titan of Canada's labor movement hangs up his skates.

Driving the Day

UNDERDOG FIGHT — The fourth major candidate for the Tory leadership officially launched his campaign at a packed hall in a fast-growing Toronto suburb that has voted Liberal three elections in a row. PATRICK BROWN, the mayor of Brampton, a former disgraced Ontario Progressive Conservative leader and former backbench MP, tossed his hat into the ring.

Ask a booster about Brown and you can bank on a version of every underdog's favorite catchphrase: "Don't underestimate him.” The thing about this young campaign is every major candidate's camp is saying the same thing.

JEAN CHAREST seemingly came out of nowhere to become premier of Quebec, as journalists who covered him at the time keep tweeting and tweeting.

— Few anticipated LESLYN LEWIS's strong third-place finish when she ran for the party leadership in 2020. "Do not ignore her," MICHAEL DIAMOND, the man who ran the campaigns that delivered DOUG FORD the PC leadership and the premier's office, tells Playbook. "She's more of a contender than Mr. Charest. She should be covered as such."

PIERRE POILIEVRE shocked Liberals when he unseated one of their Cabinet ministers, DAVID PRATT, in his first election in 2004. He won six more, even as his outer Ottawa riding became progressively more suburban and was supposed to be in play for the Liberals. He squeaked by in 2015 and has since expanded his margin.

BROWN'S PATH TO VICTORY — Brampton's mayor easily filled the Queen's Manor Event Centre within his city's limits. But don't make the mistake, say Tories who've watched him in action, of thinking Brown's persuasive powers are limited to the suburbs of the Peel, York and Durham regions that surround Toronto. He'll work to sign up hundreds of thousands of new members all over Canada.

— The 514: An ERIN O'TOOLE campaigner recalled Brown's influence on the O'Toole vs. MacKay race in 2020. One of Brown's keys to victory in the 2015 Ontario PC leadership race was intense campaigning in Tamil, Hindu, Sikh, Muslim and Filipino communities. (He also benefited from social conservative voters, as his detractors reminded Playbook.)

Five years later, this campaigner remembered Brown rallying new Tory members from similar networks to PETER MACKAY 's side on the island of Montreal. MacKay lost them to O'Toole, but Brown's groundwork helped produce plenty of first-ballot wins.

"His reach goes well beyond Ontario, and frankly goes well beyond suburban and urban Canada," says Diamond. "There are networks he's established through some of the outreach work he's done that show up in places that I think would surprise people."

Diamond's example: When Brown ran for the PC leadership, he beat CHRISTINE ELLIOTT in Stormont–Dundas–South Glengarry, a mostly rural riding that includes Cornwall, Ont. (and is now repped by MP ERIC DUNCAN).

— Key demos: Brown's opposition to Quebec's Bill 21 could make him generally unpopular in the province, but one observer noted that he doesn't have to be popular everywhere — only with enough members to put him over the top in as many ridings as possible.

His pitch for religious freedom could win over new party members in key Montreal ridings. Don't be surprised to see him in that city on a regular basis.

— One outcome: The party uses a "single-transferable vote" method. Every voting member ranks the candidates on their ballot (they don't have to rank every candidate). The candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated after each round of voting. Their votes are automatically reallocated to remaining candidates according to the second choices listed on each ballot.

Every riding is worth up to 100 points, which means a maximum of 33,800 points across Canada. (Ridings with fewer than 100 members are only allocated as many points as they have members.) The process repeats until a winner has a majority of points.

Here is how a friend of Brown sees it: Charest takes Quebec on the first ballot. Lewis drops off, and her votes largely end up with Poilievre. In the next round, Charest loses too much ground and is eliminated. Most of his votes funnel to Brown. That sets up a fourth-ballot showdown with Poilievre. Winner takes all.

— His senior team: Playbook learned over the weekend that SEAN SCHNELL , who has worked as a constituency assistant to MICHELLE REMPEL GARNER, is playing a senior role on Brown's campaign. He's based in Alberta.

FRED DELOREY is executive chair of the campaign. DeLorey last ran O'Toole's leadership campaign in 2020 before taking the reins of the Tory election campaign last year.

SET THE TONE — Poilievre was in Brown's Greater Toronto Area backyard over the weekend, stopping in at a jammed restaurant in Richmond Hill before heading to Vaughan, Oakville and, yes, Brampton. His campaign launched a two-front war on Sunday morning.

As Brown walked onto the Brampton stage, adviser JENNI BYRNE tweeted an attack vid that claimed the mayor would "say and do anything" to get elected — the same knock she (and many others) made against ERIN O'TOOLE in the middle of the last federal campaign.

The broadside racked up tens of thousands of views in its first few hours. A similar attack Poilievre leveled against Charest — "just another Liberal" — found a similar audience. "We may support different candidates, but the trash talk will take the entire party into the gutter," said Charest supporter TASHA KHEIRIDDIN in response to the video. "There will be bad blood for years after this race," tweeted former NDP national director KARL BÉLANGER.

Playbook's wisdom: This bad blood is nothing new.

— So much baggage: Brown is insistent that his mortifying near-death experience as a politician is in the rear-view mirror. Back in 2018, he faced two sets of sexual misconduct allegations that forced him to resign as party leader the same night they were broadcast on CTV News. Brown sued the network for C$8 million. The two sides settled a few days ago.

Brown's defenders claim the allegations were unfounded. He launched his campaign as the anti-cancel culture candidate. CTV did add "regrets" to the top of its explosive story for "key details" that "required correction," but most of the published details of the allegations appear to remain unchanged. No money changed hands as part of the settlement.

NOTES FROM A TELL-ALL: Brown published a blistering memoir in the wake of his hasty exit from Queen's Park. "Takedown" hit store shelves less than a year later. (It's currently on sale . Playbook nabbed a signed copy.) The book's pages are filled with score-settling. He goes after rivals who wronged him and staffers who turned away.

He also reflects on lessons learned. Here are three that may come in handy as he seeks the Tory leadership using a retooled campaign playbook:

— On big shifts: "The biggest lesson I learned is that you can only move a political party as fast as its members are willing to be moved. Some of the moves I made were done much too quickly. I was trying to change the nature of the conservative movement overnight. You cannot take a party that includes people who hate unions, and are homophobic or who are climate-change deniers and move them to a new centrist party overnight."

— On surprises: "[DAN] ROBERTSON, my former chief strategist, insisted that I make a splash at the first policy convention by announcing my belief in a carbon tax. I believe now that it was advice I should not have taken. Oh sure, it garnered a great deal of media attention and was highly successful as a communications tactic; however, as a means to start a serious conversation, it backfired terribly. It caused the party internal agony and division."

— On staffers: "We politicians leave far too much power in the hands of our hired strategists, who, rather than guide us, script us. We are often the chess pieces, while these unelected officials control the board. They are often too focused on tactics and too dismissive of principles. Frequently, they are too busy settling scores, rather than trying to fix problems."

JOKE OF THE DAY: Charest found a kindred spirit in NFL legend TOM BRADY, who un-retired Sunday after realizing he had "unfinished business" on the field. Quipped the Tory hopeful: "I feel the same way, Tom."

ALSO FOR YOUR RADAR

A TITAN STEPS AWAY — Unifor informed its members in a letter on Sunday that president JERRY DIAS is stepping down from his position as he deals with health issues. Dias had been on leave since February.

The longtime labor leader emerged in the Trudeau years as a key government ally, including on the government's signature NAFTA renegotiation with the DONALD TRUMP administration.

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS

— PM TRUDEAU is back in Ottawa. On his agenda: "private meetings."

— Poilievre is in Markham, Ont., a GTA city key to his leadership ambitions, for an announcement on immigration and labor issues.

On the Hill

— Tomorrow, Ukrainian President VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY will address a joint session of Parliament at 11:15 a.m. Parliament is back in session next Monday. Here's what's on tap at the committee level today:

11 a.m. The Special Joint Committee on the Declaration of Emergency — short form: DEDC — will formally elect its chairs. They've already been determined: Bloc Québécois MP RHÉAL FORTIN, NDP MP MATTHEW GREEN and Independent Sen. GWEN BONIFACE.

2:30 p.m. The House finance committee will keep on its own study of the Emergencies Act declaration. Witnesses include Assembly of First Nations national chief ROSEANNE ARCHIBALD; Ether Capital CEO BRIAN MOSOFF; Invest Ottawa president and CEO MICHAEL TREMBLAY; Newton Crypto Ltd's DUSTIN WALPER; and Wealthsimple chief legal officer BLAIR WILEY.

PERSPECTIVES

TWO YEARS ON — That's how much time has passed since Ottawa shut down in 2020. Yes, time is meaningless and January 2022 feels like two years ago. But the official Gregorian calendar count is two years. Here's what POLITICO reported back then.

To mark the occasion of everything that was canceled that first week (see: First Ministers Meeting, House of Commons sittings) and public figures who tested positive (SOPHIE GRÉGOIRE TRUDEAU, NBA star RUDY GOBERT), Playbook asked Liberal MP ANTHONY HOUSEFATHER to cast his mind back to those frenzied days.

Housefather's tale starts south of the border, at a conference:

— I had been a speaker at the American Israel Public Affairs Committee in Washington, D.C. JOHN BAIRD and I had done a session. And I was there with [then-Liberal MP] MICHAEL LEVITT. Also STEPHEN HARPER. There were many Canadians there.

I was there on the weekend. The week before was a constituency week, and I did all my normal things, meeting people in my office and going to events in my riding. On the Monday morning, I got up at about 5:30 so that I could do the 6 o'clock swimming practice and then get to Ottawa.

When I woke up I had an email from the Canadian group that had gone to AIPAC saying that somebody from Toronto had tested positive who had been at the conference. They advised us all to self isolate until Toronto Public Health could tell us if we were contacts of that person or not.

Michael Levitt and I reached out to PATTY HAJDU as the Minister of Health and MARK HOLLAND, our whip. And CHRYSTIA FREELAND to say, look, we've been told to self-isolate, although we don't think we were contacts. So we have to isolate.

During that period, I was doing everything virtually. I was calling into my meetings. I couldn't be at committee because they didn't have virtual stuff. I was listening on the phone, but I couldn't participate. It was as if I was already preparing for a virtual House.

I think the gravity of the situation landed on me a few days before it landed on everyone else. I was telling people that week, "Wow, this is going to be big. I have a feeling that things are not going to be as normal."

MEDIA ROOM

The New York Times reports: Shenzhen imposes a lockdown and Shanghai restricts nonessential travel as China’s new cases jump.

— From the CBC's KARINA ROMAN: Federal budget will be a 'back to basics' document responding to the chaos in Europe, sources say.

— "This podcast would be banned in Russia, and we would be in jail for producing it." On the Canusa Street pod, SCOTTY GREENWOOD and CHRISTOPHER SANDS sit down with PETER VAN PRAAGH, the head of the Halifax International Security Forum who just returned from Ukraine.

— Journalist TERRY GLAVIN goes deep on a line on JEAN CHAREST's resume that's sure to figure heavily in the months ahead: his advisory services for Huawei and MENG WANZHOU during the detention of the Two Michaels.

— What BOB RAE is reading: In the New Yorker, DAVID REMNICK interviews STEPHEN KOTKIN about where VLADIMIR PUTIN's invasion of Ukraine fits into the broader arc of Russian history. "Brilliant interview," tweeted Rae.

— The Globe and Mail's ERIC REGULY tags along on a NATO surveillance mission in Russia's vicinity.

— The Hub Dialogues devotes a roundtable to the Conservative leadership race with lots of policy discussion.

ASK US ANYTHING

TELL US EVERYTHING — What are you hearing that you need Playbook to know? Send it all our way.

Playbookers

Birthdays: HBD to CBC's CHRIS HALL and the Prosperity Institute's MIKE  MOFFATT.

HBD+3 to the Wall Street Journal's PAUL VIEIRA. HBD+4 to BuzzFeed's ELAMIN ABDELMAHMOUD, who's publishing a memoir soon.

Spotted: Legendary mayor HAZEL MCCALLION,in the pages of the New York Times. … Conservative MP ERIN O’TOOLE, returning to his podcast for the first time since 2019. … Banker and former MP LISA RAITT, rolling with Covid-19. … LISA KIRBIE, pondering cutting the cord.

Media mentions: ALISON MAH announced that March 24 will be her final day at the Ottawa Citizen. … PAUL WELLS and MARIE-DANIELLE SMITH both resigned from Maclean's last Friday. "I have many ideas about what to do next, but no specific plan. I have been unemployed for all of one week since I was 22," Wells wrote on LinkedIn. "On to the next adventure," tweeted Smith.

The Globe and Mail's KRISTY KIRKUP, in the ER with Covid : "I’m immune compromised and almost six months pregnant. You may be done with the virus. That changes nothing."

iPolitics has "lots of exciting announcements" planned for today.

Movers and shakers: KEEAN NEMBHARD, most recently a policy and international affairs adviser to Senate Speaker GEORGE FUREY, is Natural Resources Minister JONATHAN WILKINSON's newest press secretary. … VANESSA CRANSTON, once a Supreme Court comms officer and before that a Laurier House guide, is leaving MP SERGE CORMIER's office. She's now Immigration Minister SEAN FRASER's director of parliamentary affairs. ... ABDULLATIF AL-SHAIKH is now president of the National Council on Canada-Arab Relations.

PROZONE

For Pro s, here’s our PM Canada memo: The week ahead: Everyone's on alert.

In other headlines for Pros: 

Trudeau blasts social media disinformation — in Russia and Canada.
Ukraine conflict prompts countries to hoard grain, endangering global food supply.
As masks come off, vulnerable Americans feel left behind.
Canada targets ‘unintended restrictions’ in cannabis law.
Moon battle: New Space Force plans raise fears over militarizing the lunar surface.

TRIVIA

Friday's answer: JOHN TURNER is said to have saved JOHN DIEFENBAKER from drowning in the Barbados.

Props to J.D.M. STEWART, RENEE LEVCOVITCH, STEPHEN AZZI, MICHAEL SUNG, DOROTY MCCABE, FRANCIS DOWNEY, SEBASTIAN COOPER, GEORGE YOUNG, AMY BOUGHNER, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, JOE BOUGHNER, ALAN KAN, SCOTT LOHNES, JANE DOULL, GREG MACEACHERN, SEAN WEBSTER, CULLY ROBINSON, BILL DAY, NICK MASCIANTONIO and BOOTS VAISEY. 

Today’s question: Conservative MP MIKE LAKE represents Edmonton–Wetaskiwin, the largest and fastest-growing riding in Canada. Who represents the second-fastest growing riding?

Send your answers to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Andy Blatchford @AndyBlatchford

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Mar 11,2022 11:00 am - Friday

Who’s who in the backrooms

Mar 10,2022 11:00 am - Thursday

From circuit breakers to cocktail shakers

Mar 09,2022 11:00 am - Wednesday

Priceless advice for ex-politicians

Mar 08,2022 11:00 am - Tuesday

Jean Charest will soon enter the chat

Mar 07,2022 11:00 am - Monday

We asked Tories to define grassroots

Mar 04,2022 11:00 am - Friday

Five doors for Tory voters

Mar 03,2022 12:05 pm - Thursday

Hot off the presses: CPC leadership rules