Hybrid forever

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Friday Jun 09,2023 10:01 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Jun 09, 2023 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Nick Taylor-Vaisey and Zi-Ann Lum

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Nick | Follow Politico Canada

Thanks for reading Ottawa Playbook. I’m your host, Nick Taylor-Vaisey, with Zi-Ann Lum. Today, we're still watching silly season in the House, as well as what's on the agenda in the week to come. Plus, we have all the Cabinet shuffle speculation you need for your next garden party. Also, foreign diplomats are touring Canada's north.

THREE THINGS WE'RE WATCHING

‘A NEW NORMAL’ — Government House Leader MARK HOLLAND made it official Thursday. He wants the House to be permanently hybrid and laid out a plan for MPs to debate before the chamber rises for the summer.

Cue the howls from Conservative benches. Tories have long called for a full return to in-person proceedings, claiming the hybrid option allows the government to dodge accountability. They also use the House's electronic voting app on a regular basis, because convenience is a powerful drug.

— The pitch: “This is an important moment for Parliament,” Holland told the chamber after proposing changes to the standing orders. “This should be a signal that the House of the common people is a place where all can run — somebody who has a family, or who has challenges, is going to be afforded the flexibility to still represent their community.”

— Behind the move: Earlier this year, a House committee advised that hybrid proceedings and an electronic voting app in use since 2021 be maintained indefinitely. As POLITICO’s MAURA FORREST chronicled at the time, some MPs — especially younger ones — say it’s their new normal, and they’re not going back.

— Voting tomfoolery: Speaker ANTHONY ROTA dropped a dollop of passive aggression on the House in a Thursday statement.

On Wednesday, Conservatives complained of technical difficulties during marathon votes on CHRYSTIA FREELAND's budget bill. Spoiler alert: There were no technical difficulties. It was a crudely executed delay tactic, the hybrid equivalent of a slow vote.

— Rota called the Tories on it: House employees found little evidence of an app malfunction, he said. Rota found it “curious” and “even worrisome” that the complainants reported their issues from the opposition lobby, a room adjacent to the chamber — and didn't vote from their nearby seats.

— Call to order: Rota backed into the blindingly obvious conclusion: “The chair suspects that these difficulties were not technical in nature.” His message to party whips and House leaders in the room: find a way to play your games that doesn't waste everyone's time.

THE WEEK AHEAD — The House passed Freeland's budget bill at third reading in a Thursday vote. With that deck cleared, Holland laid out his government's priorities for the next week:

C-35: Families Minister KARINA GOULD's bill would enshrine long-term, fed-prov childcare funding and create the National Advisory Council on Early Learning and Child Care. MPs will debate the bill today. Holland anticipates a third-reading debate on Monday.

C-33: Today, the House will debate at second reading Transport Minister OMAR ALGHABRA's move to "strengthen the port system and railway safety."

C-41: Today, the House will also debate Public Safety Minister MARCO MENDICINO's push to allow Canadians to undergo humanitarian assistance in terrorist-controlled areas. The House unanimously passed a motion that would speed up debate on the bill, which could pass third reading as soon as today.

C-48: Justice Minister DAVID LAMETTI's bail-reform bill gets the second reading spotlight on Monday.

S-8: A Senate bill that amends immigration laws to expand the scope of inadmissibility to Canada based on sanctions will be debated at report stage on Tuesday.

C-22: Employment Minister CARLA QUALTROUGH's Canada disability benefit is back from the Senate, which submitted amendments, and will also be dealt with on Tuesday.

C-40: Also on Tuesday, Lametti's legislative effort to establish a Miscarriage of Justice Review Commission will be debated at second reading. The bill is informally known as David and Joyce Milgaard's Law.

HE'S BACK — Briefly. Virtually. Former finance minister BILL MORNEAU testified at the House transport committee, a Thursday re-do after a headset malfunction kiboshed his earlier attempt at testimony.

— On the agenda: McKinsey’s role in creating the Canada Infrastructure Bank.

— The backdrop: Morneau testified from a sterile room, the only animating feature an apparent thermostat on the wall behind him. If you know your hex codes, you'll know the backing wall was the forgettable #d7c7ac — grayish-orange, according to one website, with far more gray than orange.

If Morneau's goal was to avoid making news, mission accomplished.

— The quote to remember: Morneau described DOMINIC BARTON's former global consulting firm as "working closely with the Department of Finance in what turned out to be a particularly effective partnership."

Wait, no, that's what Morneau wrote in his memoir, “Where to From Here.” The former Cabmin wasn't nearly as precise about McKinsey's work with the feds during his hour of testimony.

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS


— Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU is in Ottawa with private meetings.

— Deputy PM CHRYSTIA FREELAND is in Toronto with private meetings.

8:30 a.m. Environment Minister STEVEN GUILBEAULT will address the International Eco-citizenship Summit, held at Montreal's Palais des congrès.

8:30 a.m. Statistics Canada releases its latest Labor Force Survey data.

8:45 a.m. Parliamentary Budget Officer YVES GIROUX and Auditor General KAREN HOGAN will be guests at the House national defense committee as MPs review procurement in the Canadian Armed Forces.

9 a.m. Conservative leader PIERRE POILIEVRE holds a press conference in Toronto.

1 p.m. (11 a.m. MT) Alberta Premier DANIELLE SMITH's Cabinet will be sworn in.

Did someone forward Ottawa Playbook your way? Click here to sign up for your own edition. It’s free!

For your radar

MUSICAL CHAIRS — It's garden party season in Ottawa, and the Hill's nonstop networkers can probably use a fresh conversation starter. Playbook presents a few talking points on the latest Cabinet shuffle speculation. Don't act like you're better than this. Embrace it.

— Will a shuffle happen? Yes. Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU will eventually demote, promote, add and subtract ministers from his Cabinet crew.

— OK, when? Shuffles can happen whenever the PM desires. Sometimes he picks a frigid January day. See: 2017, 2019. Other times, the warmth of summer. See: 2016, 2018.

We've observed an emerging consensus that a reordering of ministerial deck chairs is likely this summer. Trudeau typically reserves the first two weeks of August for a two-week family vacay in a place far from Rideau Cottage. He'll preside over a Cabinet retreat before the House returns for the fall sitting on Sept. 18.

That leaves a few weeks in August and September for new or shuffled ministers to get briefed up and comfortable with their assigned portfolios before plotting strategy and facing their foes.

— Or maybe: July. Back in 2018, that’s when Trudeau added MARY NG, BILL BLAIR, FILOMENA TASSI, JONATHAN WILKINSON and PABLO RODRIGUEZ to Cabinet.

We're hedging. Can you blame us?

— Who will move: We welcome your intel, but connected Hill people wouldn't be surprised to see JOYCE MURRAY or MARCO MENDICINO in the spotlight. Or not. The old adage often proves accurate: those who say they know almost always do not. (Unless they do.)

— A wildcard: Retirements. Ministers who don't intend to run in the next election could eventually bow out of Cabinet to allow rising stars time to burnish their credentials before hitting the hustings. Keep an eye on veteran lawmakers whose careers have run their course — and whose gold-plated pensions are well-stocked.

DUE NORTH — Global Affairs Canada (GAC) has organized its Northern Tour roughly every two years since 1972. This year, 23 diplomats took the department up on its invitation.

— Itinerary peek: Foreign diplomats left town on Monday for a two-week trip that includes 11 stops: Yellowknife, Inuvik and Ulukhaktok in the Northwest Territories; Whitehorse, Dawson City and Old Crow in the Yukon; Cambridge Bay, Resolute Bay, Pond Inlet and Iqaluit in Nunavut; and Kuujjuaq in northern Quebec.

A GAC spokesperson tells Playbook the tour is advocacy work “to educate the international community about the importance of Canada’s north while advancing reconciliation and renewing Canada’s relationship with northern Indigenous Peoples and communities.”

The diplomats, and Canada’s Chief of Protocol STEWART WHEELER, land back in Ottawa on June 15.

— Who’s traveling: Austrian Ambassador SYLVIA MEIER-KAJBIC; Belgium’s Ambassador PATRICK VAN GHEEL; Cyprus High Commissioner GEORGIOS IOANNIDES; Danish Ambassador HANNE FUGL ESKJÆR; Dominican Republic Ambassador MICHELLE COHEN DE FRIEDLANDER; El Salvador Ambassador RICARDO ALFONSO CISNEROS RODRIGUEZ.

— Plus: European Ambassador MELITA GABRIČ; Haiti’s Ambassador WIEN-WEIBERT ARTHUS; Indonesian Ambassador DANIEL TUMPAL SIMANJUNTAK; Irish Ambassador EAMONN MCKEE; Israel’s Ambassador RONEN HOFFMAN; Japanese Ambassador KANJI YAMANOUCHI; Kenya’s Ambassador IMMACULATE WAMBUA; Kuwait Ambassador REEM ALKHALED; Lithuanian Ambassador DARIUS SKUSEVIČIUS; Mali Ambassador FATIMA BRAOULÉ MÉÏTÉ.

— Plus, plus: New Zealand High Commissioner MARTIN HARVEY; Nigerian High Commissioner ADEYINKA ASEKUN; Saudi Arabia chargé d'affaires ABDULAZIZ AL BADI; Spain’s Ambassador ALFREDO MARTÍNEZ SERRANO; Swiss Ambassador OLAF ANDREAS KJELSEN; Zimbabwe Ambassador CECIL TOENDEPI CHINENERE; and Aga Khan Development Network representative MAHMOUD EBOO.

— Meanwhile in Ottawa: With nearly two dozen diplomats out of town, Foreign Minister MÉLANIE JOLY assembled senior diplomats from 155 Canadian missions around the world (representing 110 countries) back to the construction site that is GAC HQ this week to swap notes on modernizing the foreign service. A plan has been promised for the fall.

WHO'S UP, WHO'S DOWN


Who’s up: Green leader ELIZABETH MAY, whose decades of largely unheeded warnings about climate change look more prescient by the week. (HBD, BTW.)

Who’s down: Navigator, a firm known for discrete crisis comms where the goal is to be neither seen nor heard. Services rendered for foreign interference investigator DAVID JOHNSTON made plenty of headlines before the two sides parted ways.

HALLWAY CONVERSATION


CUT, CUT, CUT — Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU is test-driving the campaign slogan he hopes will slay PIERRE POILIEVRE. In major speeches and House quips, Trudeau frames his Liberals as smart investors of taxpayer money and Poilievre's Conservatives as cruel cutters of crucial programs.

FRED DELOREY, the architect of the last national Conservative campaign in 2021, offered some advice to his partisan pals: don't fight that narrative. Redefine it and own it.

DeLorey, the managing partner of DesLauriers Public Affairs, published a Substack post Thursday inspired by Poilievre's Wednesday night budget bill-blocking Commons filibuster. He talked through his thinking over the phone with Playbook. This conversation has been edited lightly for length and clarity.

What was it about Poilievre’s speech that got you thinking?

He wants to stop the budget. He’s come out now and says he wants to rewrite the whole thing. He's blaming the budget for inflation and the problems we have in front of us. The federal government has been setting massive records in spending. The only way to fix that is to cut massively. And that is what Pierre is going to do. That is going to be the plan. At his core, he’s a true fiscal conservative. He’s a true believer in that.

What do you make of the risks that come with embracing austerity? The Liberals are already weaponizing that word against Poilievre.

We have to take it head on. If the Liberals are going to accuse us of a hidden agenda, we can’t allow that. Get out in front of it because it's true. We're going to be making massive cuts, there’s no question about it. That's exactly what the leader is saying. We can own this and be truthful to Canadians and still win, I believe.

We don't need to hide behind cloaked words.

The economy and inflation are massive concerns. This may not be a good strategy in good times. When the economy's good and things are flowing, people are OK with deficits and debt. But right now, it feels like people are getting very, very worried. We saw that Canada is one of the countries most in danger of mortgage default. People are getting really worried about this stuff. I think this fits the current climate. And it's true to who Poilievre is.

This is a different approach than the 2021 campaign.

It's a whole different scenario. Inflation was beginning then, but now it’s here. It’s nasty. Things are getting bad. And the Liberals are continuing out-of-control spending. It doesn't make sense anymore. Now it’s just spending, spending, spending for the sake of it, it feels like. We just cannot, as a country, do that.

Is government spending the ballot question in the next campaign?

The next question is two years from now, potentially, so who knows what two years from now looks like. But right now, this is the top question.

MEDIA ROOM


— From Nunatsiaq News: Nunavut children going to school hungry, senators told.

— The National Post headline you never thought you'd read: Why the CRA is going after former Blue Jays for millions in taxes

— The Narwhal’s CARL MEYER reports that a federal advisory group on carbon management was itself advised by a senior executive at Suncor.

DAVID JOHNSTON and crisis comms experts at Navigator are no longer working together, report the Globe's BOB FIFE and STEVEN CHASE. The former GG was gracious in ending the relationship: “Mr. Johnston thanks Navigator for the extensive support they have provided to this point.”

DAVE COURNOYER takes stock of the Alberta NDP's future after an election result that produced a historically large opposition — but still a loss.

PROZONE


For POLITICO Pro s, our latest policy newsletter from SUE ALLAN: House vs. work from home

In other news for Pro s:

China seeking to spy on the U.S. from a base in Cuba

Sunak and Biden reach for critical minerals deal in show of unity

Russia is getting better at evading Western sanctions on electronics, U.S. official says

Pressure builds on Biden to send long-range weapons to Ukraine

EPA proposes broad ban of chemical used in dry cleaning

PLAYBOOKERS


Birthdays: HBD to Environment Minister STEVEN GUILBEAULT, federal Green Leader ELIZABETH MAY and Ontario Green Leader MIKE SCHREINER. Also former MP JEAN RIOUX (70) and former Ontario Cabmin JOHN GERRETSEN (father to Liberal MP MARK).

HBD + 1 to CityNews bureau chief CORMAC MAC SWEENEY.

Celebrating Saturday: Reform Party godfather PRESTON MANNING, former Tory Cabmin JAMES MOORE, Sen. VICTOR OH, former MP PIERRE NANTEL (60), Crestview Strategy VP ANDREW BRANDER.

Sunday birthdays: Ontario Cabmin CAROLINE MULRONEY, former Liberal MP MARIO SILVA, former MP and current commentator FRANÇOISE BOIVIN.

Send birthdays to ottawaplaybook@politico.com .

Spotted: PM TRUDEAU among a sea of federal, provincial and municipal glitterati at the Canadian Jewish Political Affairs Committee's Toronto ACTION party on Thursday night.

The winners of the hottest vote on the Hill: the Canadian Animal Health Institute's cutest pets competition. The winning dog was MATTEO. The winning cat was SHOHEI MEOWTANI. Winning "other pet" was PETUNIA the chicken. Bloomberg reporter BRIAN PLATT and son JACOB accepted Meowtani's award on behalf of his parents, Toronto Star editor ALISON MAH and photographer DAVID KAWAI.

JESSICA STERN, U.S. special envoy to advance LGBTQI+ rights, at Lornado’s Pride month fête hosted by resident Ambassador DAVID COHEN … Women and Gender Equality and Youth Minister MARCI IEN hosting Parliament’s inaugural drag brunch … Artist, author and mall buff ANDREW KING, stirring nostalgia at the once-buzzing St. Lawrence Centre (spelled the Canadian way) across the border in Massena, N.Y.

StrategyCorp's GARRY KELLER, celebrating the 11th anniversary of his life-saving kidney transplant (Keller's message: #BeADonor).

Movers and shakers: Sandstone Group signed up a trio of consultants to lobby on behalf of the CKUA Radio Foundation in Alberta: KEVIN BOSCH, SKYE SCRUTON and RONAN BOSCH (son of Kevin). Top priority: "support independent public radio."

Media mentions: Today is SAM COOPER's last at Global News. Cooper is launching an independent investigative Substack platform called The Bureau. He's dreaming big: "I have plans for building The Bureau into an international reporting channel and connecting with like-minded journalists worldwide," he wrote on LinkedIn.

On the Hill


Find upcoming House committees here
Keep track of Senate committees here

8:45 a.m. The Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers and File Hills First Nations Police Service will be among the witnesses at the House public safety and national security committee as it considers Bill C-20.

8:45 a.m. Parliamentary Budget Officer YVES GIROUX and Auditor General KAREN HOGAN will be guests at the House national defense committee as MPs review procurement in the Canadian Armed Forces.

8:45 a.m. The House official languages committee will hear from department officials as it studies increased francophone immigration to Canada.

8:45 a.m. The House human resources committee is focused on the financialization of housing. Witnesses on the roster include Parkdale Neighbourhood Land Trust, the Federation of Rental-Housing Providers of Ontario and Skyline Apartment Real Estate Investment Trust.

1 p.m. OLEKSANDRA MATVIICHUK of the Center for Civil Liberties will be among the witnesses at the foreign affairs committee’s subcommittee on international human rights.

TRIVIA


Thursday’s answer: MP JEAN CROWDER introduced the motion to adopt June as National Aboriginal History Month. The name was changed to National Indigenous History Month in 2017.

Props to MAX FINEDAY, BOB GORDON and ROBERT MCDOUGALL.

Today’s question: What sitting MP said the following of BILL CLINTON: “My mom just adored him. He's a very generous and sweet person to friends … He's just genuinely sweet to people."

Send your answer to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

Want to grab the attention of movers and shakers on Parliament Hill? Want your brand in front of a key audience of Ottawa influencers? Playbook can help. Contact Jesse Shapiro to find out how: jshapiro@politico.com

Playbook wouldn’t happen: Without Luiza Ch. Savage, Sue Allan and Emma Anderson.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Kyle Duggan @Kyle_Duggan

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Jun 08,2023 10:01 am - Thursday

Filibuster bluster

Jun 07,2023 10:01 am - Wednesday

Fires, fires, everywhere

Jun 06,2023 10:00 am - Tuesday

The very definition of silly season

Jun 05,2023 10:00 am - Monday

Byelections and budget brawls

Jun 01,2023 10:01 am - Thursday

Welcome to silly season

May 31,2023 10:02 am - Wednesday

How the world sees Canada now

May 30,2023 10:09 am - Tuesday

'Miracle on the Prairies'