Tesla's charger won. Next up: 'Adapter hell.'

From: POLITICO's Power Switch - Thursday Dec 21,2023 11:02 pm
Presented by Williams: Your guide to the political forces shaping the energy transformation
Dec 21, 2023 View in browser
 
Power Switch newsletter logo

By David Ferris

Presented by

Williams

Programming note: Power Switch will not publish next week. We'll be back in your inboxes Jan. 2. Happy holidays!

A Tesla electric vehicle is charged in Westlake, California.

A Tesla electric vehicle is charged in Westlake, California. | Mark J. Terrill/AP

America has finally sorted it out to align behind one standard — that of Tesla — when it comes to charging electric vehicles. That will carry big benefits — but also burden drivers with a confusing period of “adapter hell.”

For as long as there have been electric vehicles, there’s been a VHS-vs.-Betamax-type battle over the technology used to plug it in. Tesla, whose cars represent the lion’s share of EV sales to date, has had one standard exclusive to its cars, while most other automakers opted for another suite called the Combined Charging System (CCS).

Decisions this week by the Biden administration and an influential industry group made this national ascension nearly inevitable, writes David Ferris.

SAE, a nonprofit that sets industry benchmarks for a wide range of products, published its first set of standards Monday for the Tesla system, which it now calls J3400. And Tuesday, the Biden administration moved to make it possible for the Tesla system to be eligible for $7.5 billion in federal EV charging funds.

Tesla won this standards battle with astonishing speed.

Since May, when Ford became the first competitor to adopt Tesla’s standard, a stampede of automakers and charging companies followed. On Tuesday, Volkswagen added its name — leaving Stellantis, maker of Dodge, Ram and Jeep vehicles, as the only holdout.

This swift end to such a long standoff can be summed up in one word: reliability.

Tesla Superchargers, used to refill an EV battery quickly, generate little user complaint. CCS chargers haven’t fared as well.

As automakers that aren’t named Tesla pour new EV brands onto the roads, complaints of glitches at CCS stations have been legion, threatening to undermine future sales — and with it, the hundreds of billions of dollars that the auto industry and the Biden administration have collectively staked on the technology’s success.

America’s charging "Kumbaya" moment is only marred by the prospect of many EV drivers spending the next few years fiddling with adapters.

“Adapter hell” is what Loren McDonald, an EV charging consultant, called it. Automakers won’t build the new J3400 standard into their new cars until 2025. Until then, it is likely that the adapter itself will become a new source of complaint. Questions remain: Will automakers provide adapters? How much will they cost? Will drivers remember to bring them on trips?

Amid wobbly demand, even such niggling questions may bend the curve on EV adoption.

 

It's Thursday — thank you for tuning in to POLITICO's Power Switch. I'm your host, David Ferris. Power Switch is brought to you by the journalists behind E&E News and POLITICO Energy. Send your tips, comments, questions to dferris@eenews.net.

 

A message from Williams:

Meeting increasing energy demands while reducing emissions requires collaboration and balanced energy solutions. As a trusted operator with more than 100 years of experience in the evolution of energy delivery, Williams is leveraging its existing infrastructure to reliably meet increasing energy needs while supporting emissions reductions. Learn more about how our natural gas focused strategy embraces change and complements the growth of renewables.

 
Play audio

Listen to today’s POLITICO Energy podcast

Today in POLITICO Energy’s podcast: Annie Snider breaks down the state of water supply negotiations in Western states that rely on the Colorado River.

Power Centers

Capitol Hill.

Legislation that advanced oil leasing and a controversial gas pipeline has stymied NEPA challenges against the projects. Capitol Hill is shown. | Saul Loeb/AFP via Getty Images

NEPA? Nope.
The oil and gas industry landed a series of wins this year in court against green groups' claims that their projects violated the National Environmental Policy Act, Niina H. Farah writes.

NEPA requires federal regulators to consider the environmental impacts of projects. But the projects in question were mandated by congressional action, including the Inflation Reduction Act, and courts didn't see NEPA claims overriding that.

Environmental groups intend to press ahead with NEPA claims, with some still working their way through courts.

“The feds have acknowledged that the IRA doesn’t disturb the bulk of the NEPA process,” said Kristen Monsell, oceans program litigation director at the Center for Biological Diversity.

'Banner year' for state climate policy
Democratic-controlled state legislatures in Michigan and Minnesota moved aggressively on climate policy this year, already flush with money from the Inflation Reduction Act and riding high after better-than-expected elections in 2022, Adam Aton writes.

They're among the highlights of a year marked by climate action in states. Those that boosted oil and gas or turned down federal funds were more the exception than the rule in 2023, said Sonia Aggarwal, CEO of Energy Innovation: Policy and Technology and a former climate aide to President Joe Biden.

“On the whole, it’s really been kind of a banner year for clean energy policy in the states,” Aggarwal said.

 

A message from Williams:

Advertisement Image

 
In Other News

Chinese EVs: The Biden administration is considering increasing tariffs on electric vehicles and other Chinese imports.

NIMBY before YIMBY: A new study finds that properties within a mile of wind farms temporarily decrease in value after the project is announced.

Zone

A showcase of some of our best content.

A sign for charging electric cars is covered in snow in Tallinn, Estonia.

A sign for charging electric cars is covered in snow in Tallinn, Estonia. An update to U.S. rules governing highway signs will make it easier to point drivers to EV chargers. | Sergei Grits/AP

Electric vehicle charging stations are coming soon to a highway exit sign near you, thanks to an update from the Federal Highway Administration.

Eleven of the 45 members of the House Natural Resources Committee own shares in the energy industry, according to a review of annual financial disclosures.

The Treasury Department is expected to release tax guidance on the hydrogen industry soon; here are three issues to watch.

That's it for today, folks! Thanks for reading.

 

A message from Williams:

As we approach important climate targets, our planet is still burning more coal worldwide for electricity generation than any other time in history. Replacing carbon-intensive coal with natural gas is a readily available, pragmatic solution to dramatically reduce emissions. Globally, switching the top 5% of carbon emitting power generation plants would reduce world emissions from power generation by 30%.

Natural gas, in partnership with renewables, is the best way to efficiently and affordably meet increasing clean energy demands brought on by electrification while providing reliable backup capacity to support the growing deployment of solar and wind power. Currently, natural gas powers more American electricity generation than all renewables combined and has 100% reliability as ascribed by regulators.

Our industry can address this complex energy landscape with infrastructure developments and investments in the advancement of natural gas—a must-have complementary fuel to grow alongside renewables. Learn more.

 
 

Follow us on Twitter

Arianna Skibell @ariannaskibell

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

| Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

More emails from POLITICO's Power Switch

Dec 19,2023 11:42 pm - Tuesday

Manchin is battling Biden — again

Dec 15,2023 10:02 pm - Friday

U.S. power grids have a weather problem

Dec 13,2023 11:02 pm - Wednesday

Was COP28 worth all the fuss?

Dec 13,2023 12:17 am - Wednesday

Negotiations heat up in COP28 overtime