About that unity thing...

From: POLITICO West Wing Playbook - Thursday Jan 06,2022 10:52 pm
Jan 06, 2022 View in browser
 
West Wing Playbook

By Sam Stein, Alex Thompson , Tina Sfondeles and Max Tani

Welcome to POLITICO’s West Wing Playbook, your guide to the people and power centers in the Biden administration. With Allie Bice.

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Alex | Email Tina | Email Max

When JOE BIDEN ran for president, it was on an explicit pledge to “restore the soul” of the nation and bring unity across the partisan divide. In his speech marking the anniversary of the Jan. 6 riots, he made what amounted to a concession: Unity will have to wait.

The speech, a blistering, fairly dark reflection on the state of U.S. politics, can be viewed in a number of ways: A case for prioritizing voting rights legislation, an impassioned plea to buttress democracy, or a direct volley against former President DONALD TRUMP.

Fundamentally, however, it was Biden explaining that there can be no unity unless the forces of political division are confronted first. His former boss, BARACK OBAMA, was fond of saying that the fever would break. Biden, on Thursday, said those in power must choose to break it.

“The country is broken right now and if you think about it like a broken bone you don’t heal the bone by acting like it isn’t broken,” is how TOM PERRIELLO, the former Democratic congressman and diplomat put it. “You have to reset the bone. And if the person who broke it in the first place is standing there with a baseball bat ready to break it again, you have to protect against that bat.”

The White House had a choice. They could have treated today as an affair fit only for reflection and solemnity. Or they could have treated it as a matter of politics; a time to shun the forces that caused the riots in the first place.

They chose the latter, as summarized nicely in LAURA BARRÓN-LÓPEZ’s piece covering the speech.

And though Sen. LINDSEY GRAHAM (R-S.C.) took to Twitter to criticize the politicization of the anniversary, few others seemed concerned. It was not just because it is inherently ridiculous to insist that the remembrance of a day in which rioters tried to stop the peaceful transfer of power should now be devoid of politics; but because both sides of the ledger have come to view the events of Jan. 6 as the defining fault line in American politics.

Trump certainly does. He spent today sending out statements insisting that all the pathos was a ruse, designed to flip the script on the real victims: he and his voters.

“To watch Biden speaking is very hurtful to many people,” began one of his missives.

Biden couldn’t simply ignore the fault line. Nor could he tiptoe around it. He addressed it head on. “I did not seek this fight brought to this capitol one year ago today,” the president said. “But I will not shrink from it either. I will stand in this breach.”

For Democrats, it was soothing to see. Perriello, who had been with family and without power for the past few days, said he watched it with his mother and caught her weeping as she looked on.

“She was like, ‘This gives me hope for America again,’” he explained. “It is a silent majority moment. People want someone to stand up. This is what happens with bullies. People cower…. They wait for someone to stand up who is stronger and when someone does, they can exhale.”

The question now is whether Biden will sustain it. PATRICK GASPARD, who heads the Democratic-leaning thinking tank Center for American Progress, made the point on Twitter that what made the speech powerful was that Biden has been selective in how often he’s given a variation of it. Whether that means Biden waits until he gives an address like this again is to be seen. He and Vice President KAMALA HARRIS head to Atlanta next week to speak about the fight to protect voting rights.

“He has a sense of justice, equity, inclusive democracy, that comes more from the sting of lived experiences than from discerning study,” Gaspard said. “So it stands that he would ultimately be at his best and most natural when he’s drawing from that deep reservoir of earned moral convictions to contextualize a crisis or an opportunity.”

But Perriello added a broader point — that speechifying alone wasn’t enough. Rather, Biden and others must work to turn admonishments over Jan. 6 into actual accountability.

“Impunity almost always leads to subsequent bias whereas accountability almost always stabilizes,” he said. “In almost every case, a formal sense of accountability and truth telling are essential to establishing the core foundations of democracy and its institutions.”

Do you work in the Biden administration? Are you in touch with the White House? Are you JAMAL SIMMONS, communications director for the vice president? We want to hear from you — and we’ll keep you anonymous. Email us at westwingtips@politico.com or you can text/Signal Alex at 8183240098.

 

BECOME A GLOBAL INSIDER: The world is more connected than ever. It has never been more essential to identify, unpack and analyze important news, trends and decisions shaping our future — and we’ve got you covered! Every Monday, Wednesday and Friday, Global Insider author Ryan Heath navigates the global news maze and connects you to power players and events changing our world. Don’t miss out on this influential global community. Subscribe now.

 
 
POTUS PUZZLER

From the University of Virginia’s Miller Center

Which president served the shortest time in office?

(Answer at the bottom.)

The Oval

SCOOP — ESTHER OLAVARRIA, the deputy assistant to the president for immigration at the Domestic Policy Council and one of the key decision-makers on immigration inside the White House, is retiring, a White House spokesperson confirmed to West Wing Playbook.

SUSAN RICE, the head of the DPC, said in the statement that, “I could not be more grateful for Esther Olavarria’s myriad contributions to the Biden-Harris Administration, particularly her work to reverse the cruel and reckless policies of the previous Administration and to implement President Biden’s vision for a fair, orderly, and humane immigration system. “

She added: “I often call Esther the ‘OG’ of immigration."

A source familiar with the situation said that Olavarria has not decided what her last day will be and the White House expects she’ll keep working for some time. Olavarria is the latest White House official working on immigration to depart. TYLER MORAN, Biden’s senior adviser for migration, is leaving at the end of January, as we first reported last month.

ANOTHER DEPARTURE: CECILIA MARTINEZ, the White House’s top official on environmental justice, is leaving the administration, the AP’s DREW COSTLEY scoops in a mostly flattering goodbye piece. The departure comes a year after Biden took office with an ambitious plan to help disadvantaged communities and overhaul policies that have historically hurt them.

ARRIVALS LOUNGE: Veteran communications aide JAMAL SIMMONS is heading to the VP’s office, where he’ll replace communications director ASHLEY ETIENNE, The Hill’s AMIE PARNES scoops.

HOLY SHIT — Our colleagues BETSY WOODRUFF SWAN, CHRISTOPHER CADELAGO and KYLE CHENEY have a shocking scoop this afternoon that then Vice President-elect Harris was at DNC headquarters at the same time that a pipe bomb was placed outside of the building one year ago today. Harris’ location on Jan. 6 has been shrouded in mystery. That she was this endangered raises new sets of questions about security protocols that day.

HELLO, @NEERA: Staff secretary NEERA TANDEN today skewered conservative writer JONAH GOLDBERG for his Jan. 6th essay posted on former NYT columnist BARI WEISS’s Substack. “This is an embarrassing essay. Cultists who kill people also think they are doing the right thing in their twisted logic,” she wrote on (where else) Twitter.

In particular, she quote-tweeted this part of the post: "It is now an article of faith on the left that these [Jan. 6] goons were determined to 'destroy democracy.' But that wasn’t their actual intent. They believed Trump’s story. They believed they were saving democracy from a coup."

Weiss told West Wing Playbook that “I'm doubtful that she's read Jonah's essay based on that tweet.”

OTHER TWITTER STUFF: The White House’s @WHCOVIDResponse Twitter account , which has more than 375,000 followers, has been mostly dormant since November. We flagged this to a few people today and suddenly there was a new tweet this afternoon.

WHAT THE WHITE HOUSE WANTS YOU TO READ: A glowing CNN column by FRIDA GHITIS with the headline “Biden just threw down the democracy gauntlet.” Ghitis writes that Biden today delivered “the most powerful, blistering speech of his presidency,” and she called it a shift in his approach to the “nation’s ongoing crisis of democracy.”

White House rapid response director MIKE GWIN retweeted the column. And MATT HILL, White House senior associate communications director, retweeted Gwin’s tweet with his own take: “The American people spoke loudly and clearly when they elected President Biden — and for our democracy.”

WHAT THE WHITE HOUSE DOESN’T WANT YOU TO READ: A New York Times story by REBECCA ROBBINS, NOAH WEILAND and CHRISTINA JEWETT warning that a limited supply of lifesaving Covid-19 treatments to stave off severe cases are being rationed as the virus surges again.

“That has forced state health officials and doctors nationwide into the fraught position of deciding which patients get potentially lifesaving treatments and which don’t. Some people at high risk of severe Covid are being turned away because they are vaccinated,” they write. “Some hospitals have run out of certain drugs; others report having only a few dozen treatment courses on hand. Staff are dispensing vitamins in lieu of authorized drugs. Others are scrambling to develop algorithms to decide who gets treatments.”

THE BUREAUCRATS

ANOTHER SHOE DROPS AT FED — Federal Reserve Vice Chair RICHARD CLARIDA quietly admitted last month that he had failed to fully disclose financial trades he made at the onset of the coronavirus pandemic, VICTORIA GUIDA writes. Clarida, whose term is set to end Jan. 31, had already come under fire in October because he had moved between $1 million and $5 million out of a bond fund into a stock fund on Feb. 27, 2020. That was just a day before Fed Chair JEROME POWELL signaled that the central bank might move to cushion the economy when the pandemic hit the U.S.

But in a correction to his 2020 financial disclosure, Clarida said he had sold between $1 million and $5 million in the same stock fund three days prior to buying it, indicating that he was actively trading. In the Dec. 16 note submitted to the Office of Government Ethics, he referred to the exclusion of this information as an “inadvertent error.”

The new disclosure, reported Thursday by the New York Times, casts doubt on the explanation previously provided by the Fed, that Clarida's sale of the fund represented a pre-planned “rebalancing.”

What We're Reading

Advisers to Biden transition team call for entirely new domestic Covid strategy (NYTimes’ Sheryl Gay Stolberg)

Biden talks tough on Putin, but European allies are less ready for a fight (POLITICO’s Matthew Karnitschnig, Nahal Toosi and Paul McLeary)

What We're Watching

Vice President Harris will be interviewed by PBS Newshour’s JUDY WOODRUFF at 6 p.m. ET (stream here).

Where's Joe

The president delivered remarks at the U.S. Capitol regarding the one year anniversary of the Jan. 6 attack.

Where's Kamala

She also delivered remarks regarding the Jan. 6 attack at the Capitol.

The Oppo Book

DESTINE HICKS, associate director at the White House office of presidential personnel, didn't exactly plan on getting into politics.

When she started college, she was looking to pursue speech pathology, but after one poli sci course, she changed her mind. As one does.

“I ... went to a political science class and fell in love, and changed my major,” Hicks told South Carolina’s Times and Democrat in February 2021.

Ah yes, nothing like an analysis of parliamentary versus presidential systems to get one’s heart fluttering.

AND ABOUT THAT HAMILTON CHALLENGE: We asked you to send your best anti-Hamilton hot take because this town’s reverence for it is out of control.

The winner? EDDIE VALE, who wrote: “It's a play. I'm sure it's fine. Or even good. But sweet sassy molassy I can't take it of everyone running around like it changed their life or is the greatest thing to ever happen in the world!?!?!” For more takes like that, you can follow him here.

Eddie, it’s a musical, not a play.

 

DON’T MISS CONGRESS MINUTES: Need to follow the action on Capitol Hill blow-by-blow? Check out Minutes, POLITICO’s new platform that delivers the latest exclusives, twists and much more in real time. Get it on your desktop or download the POLITICO mobile app for iOS or Android. CHECK OUT CONGRESS MINUTES HERE.

 
 
POTUS PUZZLER ANSWER

WILLIAM HENRY HARRISON, who died 32 days after taking the oath of office in 1841. Harrison, the oldest person to serve as president prior to RONALD REAGAN , became ill after delivering his inaugural address outdoors in the cold March weather without a hat or a coat and died of a respiratory infection, probably pneumonia.

Join the Miller Center and presidential experts live online, on Jan. 13 to discuss President Biden’s first year. Register here.

Got a better question? Send us your hardest trivia question on the presidents and we may feature it on Wednesdays. We also want your feedback. What should we be covering in this newsletter that we’re not? What are we getting wrong? Please let us know.

Edited by Emily Cadei

 

Follow us on Twitter

Alex Thompson @AlexThomp

Maxwell Tani @maxwelltani

Allie Bice @alliebice

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO West Wing Playbook

Jan 04,2022 11:36 pm - Tuesday

Meet Gil Duran, the go to anti-Harris quote

Jan 03,2022 11:19 pm - Monday

WH on Omicron: Keep Calm and Carry On

Dec 23,2021 09:02 pm - Thursday

FLOTUS & The Florist: An Xmas Story

Dec 22,2021 11:02 pm - Wednesday

Biden aides catch the holiday blues

Dec 21,2021 11:18 pm - Tuesday

Is covering Psaki live worth Covid?

Dec 20,2021 11:29 pm - Monday

Rage of the left-wing machine