Patrick Brown's no good, very bad day

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Thursday Jul 07,2022 10:00 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Jul 07, 2022 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Nick Taylor-Vaisey

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Nick

Welcome to the Ottawa Playbook. I'm your host, Nick Taylor-Vaisey, with Maura Forrest. Today we delve into the drama surrounding PATRICK BROWN's two-front fight for his political career. Plus, the Senate is a long way from net zero ambitions. And if you're waiting for seatbelts on a school bus near you, don't hold your breath.

DRIVING THE DAY

Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson speaks

Boris Johnson | Jessica Taylor/UK Parliament via AP

THIS JUST IN — We begin with news from London.

As we are typing at 6 a.m ET, BORIS JOHNSON is poised to stand down after a wave of government resignations and a revolt from his own Cabinet left him unable to carry on.

POLITICO's MATT HONEYCOMBE-FOSTER and EMILIO CASALICCHIO report:

Johnson — who spearheaded the campaign for Brexit and led his party to an emphatic election victory in December 2019 — will be stepping aside soon, teeing up a race to replace him as head of the governing Conservative party, according to a close ally.

“The Prime Minister will make a statement to the country today,” said a No. 10 Downing Street spokesperson.

CONSERVATIVE CORNER

TAKEDOWN, PART DEUX? — In his feisty 2019 memoir, Brampton mayor PATRICK BROWN aired a political career's worth of dirty laundry. Brown was a year removed from a dramatic fall from grace as Ontario Progressive Conservative leader.

On Takedown's dust jacket, Brown promises a "story of betrayal, blackmail, and backroom politicking involving some of Canada's biggest political names." He named names, burning bridges with much of his former inner circle — the "seven horsemen," as he called them — including ANDREW BODDINGTON, ALYKHAN VELSHI and DAN ROBERTSON.

The disgraced leader-turned-suburban mayor also went after MPP VIC FEDELI, the interim leader who later sued Brown for defamation (and eventually settled out of court).

Seems he's reprising that take-no-prisoners approach, rhetoric and all.

— Let the accusations fly: The day after the Conservative Party's Leadership Election Organizing Committee (LEOC) booted Brown from the race, he took the offensive in an interview with CTV's EVAN SOLOMON billed as the "first extensive interview" since his disqualification. (CityNews reporter CYNTHIA MULLIGAN also claimed the first sclusi.)

(CTV's explosive allegations sank Brown's run for Ontario premier. He sued the network. Both sides settled in March. Seems like it's all water under the bridge?)

“Clearly the party establishment wanted Pierre. I’m shocked that they would take lengths this extraordinary to rob members of the party of a democratic election based on an anonymous complaint,” said Brown. “When I say this is politically corrupt, 150,000 Canadians, many for the first time, joined the Conservative Party, and their vote has been taken away.”

In an interview with CBC's VASSY KAPELOS, Brown laid the blame at the feet of PIERRE POILIEVRE's supporters: "The party establishment was nervous that Pierre Poilievre wasn't going to win. And his supporters, Pierre Poilievre's supporters, are the ones behind this disqualification." Catch Kapelos on this morning's edition of the Frontburner pod.

Brown complained of "phantom allegations" he couldn't properly defend. CPC member MADDISON LONG , a vocal Poilievre critic, called on the party to lay all the allegations out in the open for everybody to see. "Enough hearsay. The party needs to be transparent with our members and publicize the evidence."

— Hired gun: The Brown campaign has enlisted the services of criminal lawyer MARIE HENEIN, per a pair of letters tweeted by Solomon. One of the letters, signed by Henein and ALEX SMITH, another partner at her firm, claims Brown will appeal his disqualification.

Standing in the way of that effort is Sec. 3.1.10 of LEOC's rules for the campaign: "All decisions of the LEOC are final and are not subject to internal appeal or judicial review."

In the second letter, Henein and Smith ask the party — and every member of LEOC — to preserve all communications related to Brown's disqualification. That includes, they emphasize, any correspondence with members of the Poilievre campaign.

(Scroll down to SUMMERTIME READS for a timely pick by a Tory MP who happens to be a Poilievre supporter.)

— Who is LEOC, anyway? In February, the Tories appointed the 21-member committee to oversee the seven-month race for the permanent party leadership. Postmedia reported that 17 of them voted on Brown's candidacy — with 11 voting to disqualify him. CTV's Solomon has the vote at 10-6. Either way, it was far from unanimous.

This is who sits at that table:

— Chair IAN BRODIE, the former executive director of the party and chief of staff to former PM STEPHEN HARPER

— Vice-chair VALÉRIE ASSOULINE, VP of the party's National Council and municipal councilor in Dollard-Des-Ormeaux

PETE AARSSEN , an Ontario national councilor since 2021.

SHOLA AGBOOLA, a 2021 federal candidate in Manitoba's St. Boniface-St. Vital.

LEONA AGLUKKAQ, the former minister for both environment and health.

DAVID ANDERSON, a Saskatchewan MP from 2000 until 2019.

ROB BATHERSON, the Halifax-based president of the party's National Council.

DIANE CAREY, a consultant from New Brunswick.

JAMES DODDS, the chair of the Conservative Fund Canada.

STEVEN DOLLANSKY, an Alberta lawyer.

RICK EKSTEIN, a long-time party activist in Ontario.

DEBORAH GREY, the first-ever Reform MP.

BRUCE HALLSOR, a B.C. lawyer.

JUDY MANNING, a Newfoundland and Labrador lawyer.

DARRELL PASLOSKI, a former Yukon premier and 2008 Conservative candidate.

SYLVIA POIRIER, a P.E.I.-based national councilor from 2013 until 2021.

JUDITH SEIDMAN, a Tory senator since 2009.

NELLY SHIN, a B.C. Tory MP from 2019 until 2021.

TIM SYER, a Northwest Territories lawyer.

CLAUDE THIBAULT, a Quebec-based director of the Conservative Fund Canada.

SHELBY KRAMP-NEUMAN, Tory MP for Hastings–Lennox and Addington.

— G'bye: CHISHOLM POTHIER, a longtime JIM FLAHERTY aide who served as Brown's campaign spokesperson, appeared to give up on his party, calling it a "rotting corpse of an institution." But it wasn't all bad. "Some of the last 20 years were fun," he spat.

MEANWHILE, IN BRAMPTON — Brown is at the center of a stunning rift at city hall.

Deputy mayors PAT FORTINI and MARTIN MEDEIROS co-signed a letter with councilors JEFF BOWMAN, GURPREET SINGH DHILLON and DOUG WHILLANS that dropped another bomb on Brown's embattled political career.

SAN GREWAL, the founder of The Pointer, tweeted the missive Wednesday.

The quintet's letter said they succeeded in pushing city council to launch forensic investigations into "allegations of financial irregularities, nepotism and possible backroom contract irregularities" during Brown's time in the mayor's chair.

— A new front in the war: They allege a C$629,000 city contract was awarded to "a firm that employed one of Brown's closest political allies and a close friend of his main council enabler, ROWENA SANTOS. They say city staff told them "most of" the work promised under that contract was "never even done."

— Taking sides: The letter writers call out Brown's allies on Brampton council — Santos, PAUL VICENTE and HARKIRAT SINGH — for shutting down public meetings.

"We woke up this morning expecting to go to work but found out Brown had canceled the council meeting late last night, the fourth canceled city council meeting in a row, where we were supposed to deal with the ongoing investigations demanded by Brampton residents."

The Brampton Five want to "force Brown back to work." Democracy is "under siege," they complained, thanks to Brown's "abusive leadership."

Where is The Story of Patrick Brown headed next? If you happen to know, for the love of god, tell us as quickly as you can.

THE FOURTH DEBATE — Tory contenders will gather for their second unofficial debate this Friday in Calgary, just as the Stampede gets underway. The organizers at the Western Standard are charging C$25 per ticket for a show that's seemingly more diminished by the day. They initially managed to convince five candidates to hit the stage, with only PIERRE POILIEVRE no-showing. But LESLYN LEWIS eventually had a scheduling conflict. And Brown is, well, not qualified to attend.

— Who's left: JEAN CHAREST, ROMAN BABER and SCOTT AITCHISON.

Did someone forward Ottawa Playbook your way? Click here to sign up for your own edition. It’s free!

For your radar

USMCA FAILS TO REDUCE U.S. TRADE DEFICIT — As top trade officials from the United States, Canada and Mexico get together for trade talks today, one thing seems clear, writes POLITICO's DOUG PALMER: Former President DONALD TRUMP failed to reduce the U.S. trade deficit with its two neighbors by renegotiating the North American Free Trade Agreement.

U.S. trade data for July 2020, when the new U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement went into effect, through April 2022 shows the monthly U.S. trade deficit with Mexico averaged nearly $10 billion per month. The monthly trade gap with Canada averaged $4.5 billion over the same period.

In contrast, the monthly trade deficit with Mexico averaged $6.8 billion and the monthly trade deficit with Canada averaged $1.7 billion in the three calendar years before USMCA took effect. In other words, both deficits have grown under the deal Trump negotiated.

— Vancouver meeting: The growing U.S. trade gaps creates an awkward backdrop for U.S. Trade Representative KATHERINE TAI ’s get together today with Mexican Economy Minister TATIANA CLOUTHIER and Canadian Trade Minister MARY NG.

The occasion is a meeting of the USMCA Free Trade Commission to discuss implementation of the two-year-old NAFTA replacement agreement.

The three trade ministers may prefer to focus on other trade data. For example, final trade numbers for 2021 showed that Canada and Mexico were the United States’ No. 1 and 2 trading partners, displacing China, which held the top slot in five of the six prior years.

MOUNTIE FUNDING — The Prairies Economic Development Agency shoveled C$2.9 million in the direction of the RCMP Heritage Centre. Some of that money will help the facility pursue national museum status.

The new funding caught the attention of MICHEL ANDRÉ BREAU, a former political staffer for MÉLANIE JOLY.

Said Breau : "Given the current disrepute and dysfunction of the RCMP, and the woeful underfunding of Canada's six existing national museums, it is utterly ridiculous to invest $3 million towards converting the RCMP Heritage Centre into an additional national museum."

Ouch.

B.C. WATCH — B.C. jobs minister RAVI KAHLON took his name out of contention in the race to succeed JOHN HORGAN as premier. Kahlon encouraged Attorney General DAVE EBY to take the plunge.

CityNews reporter LIZA YUZDA made an early prediction: "This essentially is a clear runway for Eby to be the next leader and premier."

Also a potential contender: former NDP MP NATHAN CULLEN.

SCHOOL BUS SAFETY — Transport Minister OMAR ALGHABRA has a plan to make school buses safer — but it doesn’t include making seatbelts mandatory.

On Wednesday, he announced proposed regulations that mostly focus on making the area around buses safer: extended stop arms, cameras around the exterior of the bus and minimum requirements for the voluntary installation of infraction cameras, which can help police catch dangerous drivers around buses.

— Back in 2018: A Fifth Estate investigation showed that thousands of injuries and numerous child deaths could have been prevented in Canada and the U.S. over the preceding 30 years if school buses had been outfitted with seatbelts.

The investigation exposed problems with a 1984 study that Transport Canada had used to claim that seatbelts did not improve safety on school buses, and could actually cause injuries.

— In response: Then-transport minister MARC GARNEAU announced the creation of a task force to look into the possibility of requiring seatbelts on school buses. But in the end, the task force didn’t recommend making seatbelts mandatory, though it acknowledged three-point seatbelts “can offer an additional layer of safety by reducing the risk of ejection and lowering the risk of serious injury.”

The task force pointed to the cost of adding seatbelts to buses — C$8,000 to C$18,000 for a new bus and C$15,000 to C$36,000 for retrofitting an older bus. It also highlighted various other “challenges,” including driver liability for ensuring children wear seatbelts.

— Instead: The task force recommended changes that could improve safety outside the bus, most of which ended up in Wednesday’s proposed regulations.

— The stats: The government says 2.2 million children travel to school on school buses every day, and they are the safest form of school transportation. But every year, an average of one child is killed and 18 are injured during collisions with or around school buses

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS

— The second USMCA commission kicks off in Vancouver.

9 a.m. Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU is in Sudbury to visit a mining engineering facility.

10 a.m. Procurement Minister FILOMENA TASSI and Families Minister KARINA GOULD will make a funding announcement in Hamilton, Ont. for the Burlington Canal Lift Bridge.

10:30 a.m. Trudeau meets with members of Science North's Student Science Advisory Council.

11:30 a.m. (Newfoundland Time) Labor Minister SEAMUS O'REGAN and Premier ANDREW FUREY, alongside provincial Transportation Minister ELVIS LOVELESS and local mayors DAVE AKER and DANNY BREEN, will make an infrastructure funding announcement.

2:45 p.m. Trudeau will attend a tree planting event. He'll be joined by Environment Minister STEVEN GUILBEAULT.

3:30 p.m. Agriculture Minister MARIE-CLAUDE BIBEAU will make a funding announcement at the Club Lions de Compton in Compton, Que.

7 p.m. Innovation Minister FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE will hold a media availability to talk about recent meetings in Japan.

PAPER TRAIL

BLUNT TALK — The Other Place needs a little help in its quest to slash carbon emissions. “The Senate of Canada does not currently have the expertise required to fulfil its objective of achieving net zero by 2030,” reads a request for information posted Wednesday on a federal procurement website.

— Square one: An actual plan to hit net zero is the goal. But the RFI is only a starting point. The goal is to determine “what criteria and methodologies would be necessary to include as part of a Statement of Work for contracting an external expert.”

Translation: Tell us what we need to tell a contractor to do if we want them to develop a plan to cut emissions.

— The future job: When the Senate eventually looks for a contractor, that winning bidder's job will be to catalog the Senate's activities, quantify the emissions in each category, and then set benchmarks — including areas with the greatest emissions reduction potential — that would allow future planners to set targets. They'll also need to help the Senate track emissions to measure progress.

— But they're not there yet: This is a process. The Senate first needs to learn how to ask a contractor to recommend a plan to do all of those things. Have any ideas? Tell them!

SUMMERTIME READS

Today's picks come from Conservative MP ADAM CHAMBERS:

— Brain Food: "Wilful Blindness," by SAM COOPER . Chambers says: "A call to action and must-read for anyone interested in white collar or financial crime in Canada."

— Guilty pleasure:  "Nothing But the Truth," by MARIE HENEIN . Chambers says: "The life and story of a strong defender of democratic principles including due process, and a role model for lawyers everywhere."

Send us your reading suggestions — your brain food and your guilty pleasure! We'll share them in the Playbook newsletter.

MEDIA ROOM

NIIGAAN SINCLAIR joins The Decibel this morning. Topic of discussion: What’s going on inside the Assembly of First Nations?

— CBC News: Ontario's next Covid-19 wave is likely here, says science table . And over at the Toronto Star: Ontarians who haven’t had Covid boosters need to get them now, top doctor warns.

In the Financial Post, VASS BEDNAR asks: Why is it taking the Competition Bureau so long to rule on Amazon?

MADALYN HOWITT of Nunatsiaq News writes on Ottawa City Council’s approval of Larga Baffin’s application to build a new boarding facility for Nunavummiut receiving advanced medical care in Ottawa.

ERICA IFILL writes in The Globe: The problems with the federal data-privacy bill will disproportionately hurt marginalized Canadians.

PROZONE

If you’re a POLITICO Pro , don’t miss our latest policy newsletter: Brown goes down. Here’s what’s next.

In other news for s:
The big player in New York's climate fight: powerful unions.
U.S. report says Chinese censorship costs American companies billions.
Black Sea grain deal is close, says Erdoğan.
France to nationalize electricity giant EDF.
Supreme Court stunted EPA's climate powers. FERC rules could be next.
Biden’s other green promise.

PLAYBOOKERS

Birthdays: Former MPs VIVIAN BARBOT, LEON BENOIT and JEAN CROWDER. Former Manitoba justice minister and AG GORD MACKINTOSH also celebrates today.

HBD + 1 to JENNI BYRNE. 

Send birthdays to ottawaplaybook@politico.com.

Movers and shakers: BENOIT BASILLAIS has been appointed CEO of the Canadian Dairy Commission … CMHC president and CEO ROMY BOWERS let the ethics commissioner know she’s joined the Harvard Business School alumni board … The commish cut short the cooling-off period for SHAUN GOVENDER, a former senior political staffer at Treasury Board who now toils at the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority.

The PM's chef, CHANTHY YEN, is repping Canada at the Club des Chefs des Chefs in Madrid — a week-long meeting of the self-described "most exclusive gastronomic club in the world." Its members all serve heads of state (or in Canada's case, the head of government). The club's most recent Canadian tour was in 2017.

Send Playbookers tips to ottawaplaybook@politico.com.

TRIVIA

Tuesday’s answer: The Victoria Memorial Museum Building, also known as the Canadian Museum of Nature, was the first building in Canada built to house a national museum.

Props to KEVIN BOSCH, JOSEPH CHAMOUN, BRAM ABRAMSON, DOROTHY MCCABE, NATHAN GORDON, BRIANNA WORKMAN, NANCI WAUGH and ROBERT MCDOUGALL. 

Today’s question: Who was the first inductee to the Order of Canada?

Send your answers to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

Have a petition you want signed? A cause you’re promoting? Seeking to increase brand awareness amongst this key audience? Share your message with our influential readers to foster engagement and drive action. Contact Alejandra Waase to find out how: awaase@politico.com.

Playbook wouldn’t happen without Luiza Ch. Savage and Sue Allan.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Andy Blatchford @AndyBlatchford

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Jul 06,2022 10:01 am - Wednesday

Patrick Brown is out

Jul 05,2022 10:00 am - Tuesday

An election enforcer's final warning

Jul 04,2022 10:00 am - Monday

Is the federal bureaucracy broken?

Jun 30,2022 10:00 am - Thursday

Is the year half-full or half-empty?

Jun 29,2022 10:01 am - Wednesday

All talk, no traction

Jun 27,2022 10:02 am - Monday

The Speaker’s guilty pleasure