So much to do, so little time

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Friday Oct 14,2022 10:00 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Oct 14, 2022 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Maura Forrest

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Maura | Follow Politico Canada

WELCOME TO OTTAWA PLAYBOOK. I’m your host, Maura Forrest, with Nick Taylor-Vaisey and Zi-Ann Lum. Today, we bring you Day One of the Rouleau Commission and a look at what to expect in the days ahead. Also, the RCMP answers some questions (two weeks late). And a deputy minister steps down.

Did someone forward Ottawa Playbook your way? Click here to sign up for your own edition. It’s free!

DRIVING THE DAY


AND THEY’RE OFF — If you had visions of a legion of convoy types showing up at the launch of the Public Order Emergency Commission to defend their constitutional rights, or a crowd of Ottawa residents lining up to remind everyone of the trauma caused by the trucker protests, you would have been sorely disappointed.

There was a legion of journalists present to hear Justice PAUL ROULEAU kick off six weeks of public hearings into the government’s invocation of the Emergencies Act during the “Freedom Convoy” protests in February. And there were lawyers. Many, many lawyers.

But many of the chairs set out for members of the public remained empty. A few convoy leaders showed up, including TAMARA LICH , but didn’t speak to reporters. At the end of the day, a single convoy-esque vehicle sat outside the Library and Archives Building where the hearings are taking place, adorned with flags and painted slogans. But it wasn’t even a truck — just a small, harmless sedan.

All in all, Day One of the Rouleau Commission was a quiet, staid affair. But it did give viewers a sense of the players and the arguments that will be aired, in great detail, over the next several weeks.

— The man in charge: Rouleau gave a “modest” (his word) opening statement that lasted a mere 35 minutes. Much of it was what you’d expect: the commission will seek to learn what led the government to declare a public order emergency and whether its actions were appropriate, and Rouleau will maintain an “open mind” throughout.

But the commissioner did allow himself one brief critique of the process, pointing out that he’s been given just months to table a final report when other inquiries have had years. The Air India inquiry took more than four years to issue its report, he said, whereas he has until Feb. 20.

— Speed dating round: The commission then gave lawyers representing each of the 20-odd parties with standing a chance to introduce their positions. Those lawyers will have the right to question witnesses throughout the hearings.

First at bat was ROBERT MACKINNON, a lawyer for the federal government, who claimed the evidence will show the Emergencies Act was “necessary and reasonable.” No surprise there.

Next up, lawyers for Saskatchewan and Alberta argued the provinces weren’t told the federal government was considering invoking the act until the decision had been made, and their concerns about it were ignored. Again, no surprise.

— Where things might get spicy: A lawyer for the Ontario Provincial Police said the force had “sufficient legal authority” to deal with the protests without the invocation of the Emergencies Act. On the other hand, counsel for former Ottawa police chief PETER SLOLY said his client will explain how the emergency declaration helped end the occupation.

— The other players: A slew of other parties lined up against the use of the Emergencies Act. A lawyer representing the protesters said there was “no justification whatsoever” to declare an emergency. The Canadian Civil Liberties Association and other civil society groups argue the government had other tools to deal with the protests.

And the National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association of Canada (it’s a thing!) said declaring an emergency results in the “subtle and not so subtle erosion of the rule of law.”

— What’s on today: The commission will hear from its first witnesses today — a group of Ottawa residents who, it’s safe to say, won’t have kind words for the convoy. They include ZEXI LI , lead plaintiff of a class-action lawsuit against the protesters, and mayoral candidate CATHERINE MCKENNEY, councilor for Ottawa’s downtown Somerset ward.

— Next up: We don’t have a day-to-day schedule of who’s appearing when, but here’s the working plan: The commission will deal with the Ottawa protests first, starting with residents, then the City, the police, and finally protest organizers and participants.

Then the inquiry will move on to other protests, chiefly the blockade of the Ambassador Bridge in Windsor, Ont. and the border blockade in Coutts, Alta.

The last two weeks will be spent hearing from the federal government, including senior officials, cabinet ministers and Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU. The total witness list currently numbers 65 people.

— Meanwhile, on Twitter: #POEC has taken off, and we here at Playbook would like to register our profound disapproval. How are you even supposed to pronounce that? “Poke”? “Poe-eck”? “Poe-cee”? None of these are acceptable options.

For your radar


BETTER LATE THAN NEVER — On Sept. 28, your Playbook host sent the RCMP some questions about its use of facial recognition technology. The questions related to a story, published two days later , about how the police force has used facial recognition tools other than Clearview AI, despite having divulged little information publicly about the programs at its disposal.

We had basically concluded the RCMP wasn’t going to bother responding to our questions when, lo and behold, at 11:34 p.m. on Wednesday night, a full two weeks after we sent the request, a response arrived.

— If you missed the original story, here’s the gist: The RCMP recently revealed in documents tabled in the House of Commons that it has signed contracts to use multiple facial recognition tools. Most notably, the RCMP says it has been using Traffic Jam and Spotlight, two programs designed to help law enforcement fight child sexual exploitation, since 2016.

The police force said it has stopped using the facial recognition capabilities of these programs in the wake of the Clearview AI debacle. But it still hopes to use facial recognition again in the future.

— What did the RCMP have to add? In answer to questions from POLITICO, the RCMP says it will not use facial recognition until it’s completed a “comprehensive operational policy” for the use of this technology. That policy is still in the works.

In addition, each individual tool will need to be screened through an internal “national technology onboarding program” (set up in response to the Clearview AI controversy) and will need a privacy impact assessment submitted to the federal privacy watchdog.

— A quick note: The privacy commissioner’s office told POLITICO the RCMP raised its use of Traffic Jam and Spotlight this past summer, but has not yet submitted impact assessments for those tools.

— What else? The RCMP pointed out that Traffic Jam and Spotlight “are much more limited in scope” than Clearview AI. Where Clearview AI made waves for scraping three billion photos of people from the internet and selling access to law enforcement, Traffic Jam and Spotlight “only collect data from advertisements posted on websites for sexual services,” the RCMP says. “The archived ads can then be searched by investigators to support human trafficking and online child sexual exploitation investigations.”

— One more thing: The police force confirmed it “is no longer making any use, either directly, or indirectly of Clearview AI, and has no intention of doing so in the future.”

WHO SAID NEW BRUNSWICK IS BORING? — We have certainly never thought, let alone said, such a thing.

On Thursday, the province’s erstwhile education minister, DOMINIC CARDY, resigned his cabinet post in spectacular fashion — an open letter in which he accused Progressive Conservative Premier BLAINE HIGGS of a litany of sins.

— Here are some choice excerpts:

  • “Change requires care, not a wrecking ball.”
  • “You cannot change deadlines on large systems based on your emotional state.”
  • “Reform is about inspiring movement, not ordering people to move.”
  • “Too many good people have left on bad terms, on your watch.”

— And then, of course: There was the truly delightful part in which Cardy accused Higgs of yelling “Data my ass” at a senior civil servant during a meeting.

Higgs has actually admitted saying this, though he disputes the context. If you’d care to read the full story, here’s an excellent account from the CBC’s JACQUES POITRAS.

— Meanwhile, to all federal politicians with an ax to grind: We hope you’re taking notes.

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS


6:30 a.m. (10:30 a.m. GMT) Governor General MARY SIMON will participate in a discussion on gender equality and diversity in Arctic leadership as part of the Arctic Circle Assembly in Reykjavik, Iceland.

9 a.m. The parliamentary budget officer will publish a report estimating the cost of a one-time top-up to the Canada Housing Benefit.

11 a.m. (12 p.m. ADT) Justice Minister DAVID LAMETTI and Public Safety Minister MARCO MENDICINO will hold a press conference to conclude a meeting with their provincial and territorial counterparts in Dartmouth, N.S.

11:30 a.m. Heritage Minister PABLO RODRIGUEZ will be in Montreal to announce the organizations receiving funding from the Canada Performing Arts Workers Resilience Fund.

11:45 a.m. Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU will visit a local environmental organization in the Waterloo Region. At 1:45 p.m., he’ll meet with local farmers to discuss the federal carbon tax rebates. Elsewhere on the PM’s itinerary: a call with Suriname President CHANDRIKAPERSAD SANTOKHI.

12:30 p.m. (9:30 a.m. PDT) Transport Minister OMAR ALGHABRA will be in Vancouver to make an announcement about strengthening Canada’s supply chains.

12:45 p.m. (11:45 a.m. ADT) Official Languages Minister GINETTE PETITPAS TAYLOR will be in Souris, P.E.I. to announce support for the Prince Edward Island potato sector. Veterans Affairs Minister LAWRENCE MACAULAY will also attend.

WHO'S UP, WHO'S DOWN


— Who’s up: JASRAJ SINGH HALLAN, for nabbing the much-coveted role of Conservative finance critic.

— Who’s down: Alberta Premier DANIELLE SMITH , who marked her first week on the job by claiming that the unvaccinated “have been the most discriminated-against group that I’ve ever witnessed in my lifetime.” Cue the embarrassing international headlines.

MEDIA ROOM


— In La Presse, the Business Council of Canada's ROBERT ASSELIN warns of the potentially dire consequences for Canada if Alberta and Quebec refuse to compromise in good faith with the federal government.

— “We believe that this is our neighborhood,” Foreign Affairs Minister MÉLANIE JOLY told Bloomberg’s BRIAN PLATT at the end of a week-long visit to Japan and South Korea.

— In an interview with the CBC’s RAFFY BOUDJIKANIAN , Environment Minister STEVEN GUILBEAULT says something almost no politician ever says: That people living in areas vulnerable to natural disasters may have to move.

POLITICO’s KYLE CHENEY and NICHOLAS WU break down the Jan. 6 select committee’s subpoena of President DONALD TRUMP.

And from our POLITICO colleagues in Europe: The German government on Thursday declassified a 2021 security assessment of the Nord Stream 2 pipeline that claimed energy supplies “won’t be jeopardized” by increased dependence on Russian gas.

PROZONE


For POLITICO Pro s, catch up to our latest policy newsletter by ZI-ANN LUM: 30 days of fireworks, en garde.

In other news for s:

US trade rep confident electric vehicle tax credit concerns can be resolved.

Build your climate disclosures for companies from global standards, FSB tells G20.

Democrats push their vision for accelerating infrastructure work.

Biden administration examining cybersecurity of water, communications, health care sectors.

NATO rushing to build up air defenses for Ukraine — and itself.

PLAYBOOKERS


Birthdays: HBD to former Ontario attorney general CHARLES HARNICK and former Quebec transport minister MICHEL DESPRÉS.

Send birthdays to ottawaplaybook@politico.com.

Spotted: Ambassador STÉPHANE DION presenting his credentials to French President EMMANUEL MACRON and meeting with Chambre de Commerce France-Canada president DANIEL JOUANNEAU

Sen. PETER BOEHM visiting Kuwait’s Ambassador to Canada REEM ALKHALED in Ottawa… Japanese Prime Minister FUMIO KISHIDA’s office releasing pictures of his “courtesy call” with Foreign Affairs Minister MÉLANIE JOLY.

Radio-Canada, using “iel” pronouns to refer to Ottawa mayoral candidate CATHERINE MCKENNEY.

A mixed bag of parliamentarians in Strasbourg, France for the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe: Sen. PERCY DOWNE, Liberal MP FRANCESCO SORBARA, Bloc MP STÉPHANE BERGERON, NDP MP DON DAVIES and Tory MP LARRY BROCK.

Movers and shakers: Fisheries and Oceans Canada deputy minister TIM SARGENT told the department's staff Thursday that he was stepping down — effective the same day.

Crestview's JOHN O'LEARY is repping the Retail Council of Canada on the Hill. The RCC was recently at a House committee standing up for Canada's grocers, which are in the NDP's crosshairs … Hill + Knowlton's DANIEL KOMESCH signed up Volvo Group North America, which is keeping an eye on federal EV policy and regulations.

Media mentions: CBC Radio host SHELAGH ROGERS is the Confederation Centre of the Arts’s 2022 Symons Medal recipient and used her lecture to share advice she’s held on to “like a precious stone” from a residential school survivor: “Shut up and listen.”

On the Hill


Find the latest House committee meetings here.

Keep track of Senate committees here.

TRIVIA


Thursday’s answer: Canada's secret plan to invade the United States, devised in 1921 by Lieut. Col. James "Buster" Sutherland Brown, was Defence Scheme No. 1.

Props to MARTIN CHAMPOUX, BRAM ABRAMSON, ANNE-MARIE STACEY, GABRIEL CASSIE, JEFFREY GEORGE, ALLAN FABRYKANT, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, LAURA JARVIS, CHRIS MCCLUSKEY, TANIA ENSOR, PETER MCKINNEY, GWENDOLYN MONCRIEFF-GOULD

Friday’s question: A Canadian Institute of Public Opinion poll released on Sept. 30, 1943 gave this political party its first-ever national lead in the polls. Name the party.

Send your answers to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

Playbook wouldn’t happen: Without Luiza Ch. Savage, Sue Allan and Mike Zapler.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Oct 13,2022 10:00 am - Thursday

Over to you, Justice Rouleau

Oct 12,2022 10:01 am - Wednesday

Slouching toward ‘freedom’

Oct 11,2022 10:01 am - Tuesday

Public Inquiry Week is finally here

Oct 07,2022 10:01 am - Friday

The fall and rise of Danielle Smith

Oct 06,2022 10:01 am - Thursday

Kenney’s best next act ever

Oct 05,2022 10:01 am - Wednesday

China policy hide-and-seek

Oct 04,2022 10:01 am - Tuesday

That wasn't even close