Biden’s broken promise to SIV holders

From: POLITICO West Wing Playbook - Monday May 16,2022 10:18 pm
Presented by Chamber of Progress:
May 16, 2022 View in browser
 
West Wing Playbook

By Alex Thompson and Allie Bice

Presented by Chamber of Progress

Welcome to POLITICO’s West Wing Playbook, your guide to the people and power centers in the Biden administration.

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Alex | Email Max

HAMDULLAH believed America would keep its promises under JOE BIDEN.

But so far it hasn’t.

A former Afghan interpreter for the U.S. Army who qualified for a Special Immigrant Visa (SIV) last year, Hamdullah has not been able to get out since. He fears for his safety, so much so that we’re using a pseudonym to protect his identity — though we confirmed his service through photos, documents, emails, and a U.S. soldier who served alongside him.

His story is that of an overwhelmed bureaucracy ill-equipped to match the administration’s optimistic rhetoric and of the media and political leader’s attention turning to the next crisis.

Hamdullah had been scheduled to fly out of Afghanistan on Aug. 14. But the flight was canceled as the Taliban took over Kabul. His passport was at the American embassy and destroyed as part of evacuation procedures.

He was among the group of Afghans who the president’s team pledged they’d not forget — the individuals who risked their lives for a war Biden concluded was unwinnable.

But, over time, the Biden administration has not met that commitment for Hamdullah and others. Last week, in a meeting with outside advocates for such Afghans, the State Department said they now estimate there are between 70,000 and 160,000 Afghans eligible for SIVs, reserved for people who directly assisted the U.S. effort. That’s up from the 62,000 estimate last year. Given the current rules and bureaucracy, the administration has issued about 9,500 SIVs since they came into office.

“[Hamdullah] served during some heavy fighting – he proved his worth and showed his loyalty,” said DIRK RINGGENBERG, a former Army captain and Silver Star Medal recipient who served with Hamdullah and has been trying to get him out since 2012.

Ringgenberg, who now teaches military history at the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, stressed that he was only sharing his personal opinions and noted that the U.S. evacuated a lot of people last August. But, he said, “we as Americans cannot forget our friends who supported us. All efforts to ensure their safety – we should do that. That’s the promise of America.”

Ten days after Hamdullah’s first scheduled flight was canceled, he emailed the SIV team at State. They replied to his message a month later, on Sept. 25, according to the emails we reviewed. Citing “a very high number of inquiries over the past month,” the National Visa Center (NVC) explained it was “experiencing delayed response times as we work to get a response to every inquiry.”

On Oct. 7, an American volunteering with Team 13 — an ad-hoc group of volunteers that began helping Afghans evacuate the country last summer — also took on Hamdullah’s case and emailed the State Department. The volunteer requested anonymity for fear that appearing to criticize the administration would hurt the chances of other Afghans with whom she is working to get out of the country.

There was no reply to her Oct. 7 email or when she followed up on Nov. 8.

On Nov. 11, POLITICO’s NatSec Daily included a few paragraphs about Hamdullah’s situation. On Nov. 16, the State Department reached out to POLITICO offering an off the record conversation with Ambassador TRACEY JACOBSON, then the State Department’s point person for “Operation Allies Refuge. ” We won’t include the content of the conversation under the rules of it, save to say we passed along the documents we had received.

The volunteer with Team13 sent more documents to State on Nov. 16, and followed up on the 17th and 21st. She never got a reply.

Hamdullah also emailed on Nov. 27 — contacting five different state.gov email addresses used for the SIV program.

He got an auto-generated “thank you for your email” note from the NVC.

Hamdullah managed to obtain new passports for himself and his family in the new year. But State department flights had largely stopped in December and January.

He emailed the State Department again on Jan. 27. He received a reply on May 9 from a visa processing specialist confirming that the NVC “completed the processing of your case.” The government recently booked him on another flight out but it was from Kabul despite the fact that the government had been notified he recently fled to Pakistan for safety.

Hamdullah is optimistic he and his immediate family will make it to America even as he remains despondent about the thousands of his countrymen who do not have media attention and well-connected Americans helping them. In a Signal message, he told us that “after the Taliban took over and we were left behind, I was expecting a rapid response from the U.S. government to address the issues and resolve it in a good and timely manner, but it never happened.”

“We feel ashamed while meeting friends [who] are approved for Canadian immigration. They are people who have only a tiny link with Canadian government but [are] still well taken care of,” he continued. “But us who sacrificed everything for our country and [the] US mission in Afghanistan have been here suffering. It’s all unfortunate. I am [a] positive thinking person and I have been through a lot in my life and I know and believe we will get through this one too, but it hurts sometimes and I hope it’s over soon.”

Read West Wing Playbook tomorrow for our look at the overwhelmed bureaucracy trying to evacuate SIV’s. Have something we should include? Text/Signal/Wickr Alex at 8183240098.

TEXT US — ARE YOU SCOTT WEINHOLD at the State Department? We want to hear from you on your final day. Or if you think we missed something in today’s edition, let us know and we may include it tomorrow.  Email us at westwingtips@politico.com.

 

A message from Chamber of Progress:

New polling shows that American voters do not see regulating tech companies as a priority. Their top concerns are strengthening the national economy (38%), followed by controlling inflation (37%). By contrast, only 5% of respondents prioritized regulating tech companies.

Learn more about the survey results here.

 
POTUS PUZZLER

Which first lady once said: “I know what’s best for the president. I put him in the White House. He does well when he listens to me and poorly when he does not.”

(Answer at the bottom.)

The Oval

White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre

KJP PREMIERES: White House aides were closely watching press secretary KARINE JEAN-PIERRE’s debut, both for the history she was setting and to see how she’d do. “My presence at this podium represents a few firsts: I am a Black, gay, immigrant woman, the first of all three of those to hold this position,” she said near the top, addressing a very crowded briefing room.

She didn’t make any obvious mistakes beyond little things, like saying AFT when she meant ATF (Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives).

But she did lack specificity at times. She said the administration would call out hateful rhetoric but repeatedly declined to call out anyone by name. Asked about the recently released data on China’s declining industrial output that is rattling markets and promoting recession fears, Jean-Pierre said, “I have not seen that specific data that you’re speaking of.” And she deflected several questions about “how does raising taxes on corporations reduce inflation?”

Jean-Pierre also used the phrase “will check in with our team,” when responding to a few questions, and we’ll keep tabs on whether or not that’s the new version of former press secretary JEN PSAKI’s “circle back” response. Psaki also praised her successor, tweeting: “Great job on day one. Rooting for you from home.”

WHAT THE WHITE HOUSE WANTS YOU TO READ: LARRY SUMMERS’s tweets. Really! The economist who sometimes (ok, quite regularly) gets under the White House’s skin said this morning that billionaire JEFF BEZOS was “mostly wrong” when the Amazon founder said Biden was misdirecting the public by “mushing” together raising corporate taxes and fighting inflation.

Summers wrote that “it is perfectly reasonable to believe, as I do and @POTUS asserts, that we should raise taxes to reduce demand to contain inflation and that the increases should be as progressive as possible.”

WHAT THE WHITE HOUSE DOESN’T WANT YOU TO READ: This story by CNN’s MJ LEE about the problems with the White House’s new website to help those in need of baby formula. Lee tested out HHS.gov/formula and wrote: “The exercise resulted in apologetic customer service representatives, one hold time that lasted well over an hour, and serious challenges in finding baby formula through some of the main suggestions listed on the new HHS website.”

BEZOS V. BATES: Deputy press secretary ANDREW BATES hit back at Bezos’ critical comments over the weekend, writing that “it doesn’t require a huge leap to figure out why one of the wealthiest individuals on Earth opposes an economic agenda for the middle class.” For good measure, Bates also retweeted Summers' post defending the president.

Bezos responded via Twitter: “Look, a squirrel! This is the White House’s statement about my recent tweets. They understandably want to muddy the topic. They know inflation hurts the neediest the most. But unions aren’t causing inflation and neither are wealthy people.”

UNDER WHCA WATCH: White House Correspondents’ Association President and CBS News Radio White House Correspondent STEVEN PORTNOY sent an email to Today News Africa’s SIMON ATEBA. Obtained by Mediaite’s JACKSON RICHMAN, the letter calls him out for interrupting other reporters during Friday’s press briefing. During the briefing, Ateba interjected and asked press secretary Jen Psaki to take questions from reporters in the back rows.

 

DON’T MISS CONGRESS MINUTES: Need to follow the action on Capitol Hill blow-by-blow? Check out Minutes, POLITICO’s new platform that delivers the latest exclusives, twists and much more in real time. Get it on your desktop or download the POLITICO mobile app for iOS or Android. CHECK OUT CONGRESS MINUTES HERE.

 
 
THE BUREAUCRATS

YELLEN’S TURN: Treasury Secretary JANET YELLEN stopped in Warsaw, Poland on Monday, ahead of her meeting of the finance ministers of the Group of Seven leading nations. There, she visited a World Central Kitchen that’s helping feed those fleeing from Ukraine, via WSJ’s ANDY DUEHREN.

DALEEP’S FILL-IN: MIKE PYLE, Vice President KAMALA HARRIS’s chief economic adviser, is set to temporarily leave the office to serve as the National Security Council’s acting deputy national security adviser for international economics, filling in for DALEEP SINGH, WaPo’s TYLER PAGER reports.

THREE WHITE HOUSE PERSONNEL SCOOPS, all from our very own DANIEL LIPPMAN: 

  • ANGELA KRASNICK has joined the White House as director of platforms in the office of digital strategy. She most recently was content curator at Instagram.
  • KALISHA DESSOURCES FIGURES on Friday left the White House where she was special assistant to the president for gender policy, three people familiar with the matter told Lippman. She is going to be consulting for a number of organizations, including Civic Nation and National Crittenton.
  • CARISSA SMITH also recently left the White House, where she was senior adviser on women and girls and health for the office of public engagement, two people familiar with the matter told Lippman.
Agenda Setting

FEVER DREAMS: POLITICO’s JONATHAN LEMIRE had a few new details today on the Biden team’s internal debates and recent shift towards more partisanship. Among them: that senior adviser STEVE RICCHETTI “told Biden after that infrastructure bill passed that he didn’t think the GOP would bargain anymore.”

Much of the communications staff, including the just-departed Psaki, advised a more aggressive stance. And first lady JILL BIDEN told confidants that she was urging her husband to be less scripted and more on the offensive.”

 

A message from Chamber of Progress:

Advertisement Image

 
What We're Reading

Biden Approves Plan to Redeploy Several Hundred Ground Forces Into Somalia (NYT’s Charlie Savage and Eric Schmitt)

Where's Joe

Biden received the President’s Daily Brief this morning.

The president also awarded Public Safety Officer Medals of Valor in the East Room.

President Joe Biden awards Stamford, Ct., Fire Fighter John Colandro the Public Safety Officer Medal of Valor in the East Room of the White House.

President Joe Biden awards Stamford, Ct., Fire Fighter John Colandro the Public Safety Officer Medal of Valor in the East Room of the White House. | Andrew Harnik/AP Photo

He also held a bilateral meeting with Greek Prime Minister KYRIAKOS MITSOTAKIS. He and Jill Biden then hosted a reception for Mitsotakis and his wife, MAREVA.

Where's Kamala

She traveled to Abu Dhabi today, where she had a condolence visit with the President of the United Arab Emirates, SHEIKH MOHAMMED BIN ZAYED AL NAHYAN. She left Abu Dhabi in the evening.

 

INTRODUCING DIGITAL FUTURE DAILY - OUR TECHNOLOGY NEWSLETTER, RE-IMAGINED:  Technology is always evolving, and our new tech-obsessed newsletter is too! Digital Future Daily unlocks the most important stories determining the future of technology, from Washington to Silicon Valley and innovation power centers around the world. Readers get an in-depth look at how the next wave of tech will reshape civic and political life, including activism, fundraising, lobbying and legislating. Go inside the minds of the biggest tech players, policymakers and regulators to learn how their decisions affect our lives. Don't miss out, subscribe today.

 
 
The Oppo Book

Before leaving her post as press secretary, Jen Psaki admitted she had considered swiping a few things from the White House.

The first would be some of the notecards.

“I will miss them,” she said in a White House’s YouTube video posted on her last day, May 13. “I may bring some home with me.”

Another would be candy.

“There’s also taffy from Delaware and there’s a big glass jar of it outside of the Oval Office,” she said. “And I will say sometimes you just need a little sweet treat, and I will miss that when I leave the White House.”

POTUS PUZZLER ANSWER

FLORENCE HARDING was once quoted saying that and was known for pushing WARREN HARDING to enter politics, according to History.com.

A CALL OUT — Think you have a more difficult trivia question? Send us your best question on the presidents with a citation and we may feature it.

Edited by Eun Kyung Kim and Sam Stein

 

A message from Chamber of Progress:

New polling shows voters' top tech policy concerns are cybersecurity and data privacy. Only 7% of respondents prioritized antitrust action and only 1% prioritized changes to app store rules.

In fact, the majority (58%) believe the pending tech antitrust legislation would cause more harm than help to consumers. Between June 2021 and March this year, 79,000 voters signed petitions urging policymakers to oppose legislation that would disrupt the use of tech products and services, endanger their privacy, and prevent online platforms from addressing hate speech and misinformation.

During recent hearings on the pending legislation (S.2992) in the Senate, Democratic policymakers voiced similar concerns about the bill, including its harms to consumers, national security, and privacy. A round up of these concerns is available here.

 
 

Follow us on Twitter

Alex Thompson @AlexThomp

Maxwell Tani @maxwelltani

Allie Bice @alliebice

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO West Wing Playbook

May 13,2022 09:54 pm - Friday

A-mos powerful Biden aide

May 12,2022 09:31 pm - Thursday

War on Women redux

May 11,2022 10:09 pm - Wednesday

Biden’s (now pricey) goose may be cooked

May 10,2022 10:03 pm - Tuesday

The first rule of being a Biden speechwriter

May 09,2022 10:49 pm - Monday

John Edwards' shadow

May 05,2022 09:57 pm - Thursday

Symone Sanders is ready for her close up