What Biden really thinks of the Jan. 6 commission

From: POLITICO West Wing Playbook - Friday May 21,2021 10:10 pm
May 21, 2021 View in browser
 
West Wing Playbook

By Sam Stein and Theodoric Meyer

With help from Allie Bice and Daniel Payne

Welcome to POLITICO’s West Wing Playbook, your guide to the people and power centers in the Biden administration. Did someone forward this to you? Subscribe here! Have a tip? Email us at transitiontips@politico.com.

With Democrats’ hopes for a commission to investigate the Jan. 6 Capitol riots fading, President JOE BIDEN has stayed notably quiet.

It is not for lack of opinion about the riots or the need to investigate them, but, rather, a manifestation of the White House’s belief that the best course of action when it comes to Trump-era accountability — at least right now — is strategic distance.

From conversations with Biden confidantes, two threads emerge regarding his approach and thinking around the Jan. 6 commission. The first is that he wants it. Yes, the administration has put out a statement of support for the legislation that would create such a body. But beyond that, the president fundamentally believes it’s necessary to conduct a thorough reckoning of what led to the ransacking of the Capitol and the larger threats posed to democracy. That he spent such a large portion of his address to a joint session of Congress warning of those threats was no accident—it was the very theme that he’d used at the launch of his campaign.

“He does see this as a genuine hour of crisis for democracy,” said a source who has talked to Biden about these matters. “He feels it viscerally, that he’s spent fifty years devoted to the American experiment and this guy [Trump] is just gonna flush it all down the drain.”

In that vein, Biden stands somewhat apart from the man he once served, President BARACK OBAMA , who resisted investigating the Bush administration for its authorization and use of torture.

But Biden is similar to Obama in one important way, and that constitutes the second thread. He sees no upside in pushing aggressively for the commission’s creation. In fact, the White House thinks its involvement could backfire — hurting the perception that the commission is a sober-minded, apolitical concept and imperiling its creation.

For that reason, the administration has almost entirely deferred to Congress. Two top Hill Democratic aides said they were unaware of any White House involvement at all.

“They see this as a congressional thing, that it’s about a breach of the Capitol,” said one of those aides.

Not everyone views the arms-length approach as a particular stroke of strategic genius. Among some Biden allies there is concern that officials in the White House have over-internalized the oft-attributed (likely inaccurately) Napoleon maxim: “Never interfere with an enemy while he’s in the process of destroying himself.”

ALKA PRADHAN , a human rights attorney who has written about the need for Biden to unflinchingly investigate a host of Trump-era decisions and policies, argued that there is simply no intellectual space for political leaders to remain muted on the commission. Biden may not want to politicize the commission. But it’s happening without him, as DONALD TRUMP scolds Republicans who vote for it and intimidates those who may soon have to vote.

“The administration has a tightrope to walk between getting their agenda passed with enough votes and showing leadership that we haven’t seen in several years,” she said. “But at the same time, the events of Jan. 6 in particular were so egregious, crossing lines of illegality that we have not seen domestically in decades or much longer than that, that they needed to come out swinging on that issue. I don’t think they should have left it solely up to congressional leaders to figure out how there was going to be accountability for this.”

“I don’t think they’ve done enough,” Pradhan concluded.

Whether, in fact, they are doing enough will soon become clear. The Senate is expected to vote on the House-passed bill creating the commission. And Democrats are particularly adamant that Republicans pay some price if they choose to filibuster it.

“Make these fuckers vote on it,” declared the other aide.

Should that filibuster happen, then Biden will face a choice. He could keep looking forward: speaking out about the need to protect democracy, making policies that affirm the independence of the judiciary, tackling reforms to strengthen voting, and so on. Or he could do whatObama resisted doing: look backward, push for a fall-back alternative to the Jan. 6 committee, and encourage lawmakers, investigators and others to investigate other Trump-era blunders, chief among them the Covid response.

The White House, as has been its want throughout this entire process, is cagey about where Biden will come down on this one. But if past is prologue, he might have more appetite for accountability politics than the public thinks, and certainly more than Obama did.

Back during the close of the 2008 presidential campaign, as then-candidate Obama was reinforcing his reluctance to prosecute Bush administration officials because he felt it would divide the country, one prominent member of his campaign strayed off script: Biden.

“If there has been a basis upon which you can pursue someone for a criminal violation, they will be pursued,” he said, causing headaches for the Obama campaign, “not out of vengeance, not out of retribution—out of the need to preserve the notion that no one, no attorney general, no president, no one is above the law.”

PSA — We’re going to be experimenting with some new items and sections. Tell us what you like and what you hate.

Do you work in the Biden administration? Are you in touch with the White House? Are you REBECCA BROCATO?

We want to hear from you — and we’ll keep you anonymous: transitiontips@politico.com. Or if you want to stay really anonymous send us a tip through SecureDrop, Signal, Telegram, or Whatsapp here. You can also reach Alex and Theo individually.

PRESIDENTIAL TRIVIA

With the Partnership for Public Service

Today is National Bike to Work Day! Which president hosted a 100k bike ride to honor the country’s servicemen?

(Answer is at the bottom.)

Cartoon of the Week

Cartoon from Kevin Kallaugher for The Economist

Cartoon | Kevin Kallaugher/The Economist

Every Friday, we’ll feature a cartoon of the week — this one is courtesy of The Economist. Our very own MATT WUERKER also publishes a selection of cartoons from all over the country. View the cartoon carousel here.

The Oval

WHITE HOUSE: YOU, TOO, CAN FIND LOVE ONLINE — “We have finally found the one thing that makes us all more attractive: a vaccination,” ANDY SLAVITT , a White House senior adviser on Covid, told reporters today as he touted OkCupid and other dating apps’ efforts to encourage people to get vaccinated. But don’t take Slavitt’s word for it!

“I met my fiancé on Hinge - just saying!” White House deputy communications director KATE BERNER tweeted this morning.

ANOTHER DONILON IN THE WHITE HOUSE: SARAH DONILON is working under KURT CAMPBELL, the national security council’s Indo-Pacific coordinator, as a special assistant in the NSC’s Asia directorate, DANIEL LIPPMAN reports. Donilon, who previously worked on Biden’s transition team, is fluent in Mandarin, according to two people familiar with the matter.

She also has a family connection to the West Wing: She’s the daughter of CATHY RUSSELL, who heads the Presidential Personnel Office, and the niece of MIKE DONILON, Biden’s senior adviser.

She’s not the only child of a top Biden aide in the administration.

As we noted last week, JULIA REED, whose father is White House deputy chief of staff BRUCE REED, is Biden’s day scheduler. SHANNON RICCHETTI, the daughter of White House counselor STEVE RICCHETTI, is deputy associate director of the White House social secretary. And Steve Ricchetti’s son, DANIEL RICCHETTI , is a senior adviser in the office of the under secretary of State for arms control and international security.

Agenda Setting

THE PRICE AIN’T RIGHT — The Biden administration on Friday said it was slashing the price tag on an infrastructure proposal by more than $500 billion in an attempt to win Republican support.

But BEN LEONARD, CHRIS CADELAGO and NATASHA KORECKI report that the offer was received with scorn by Senate Republicans, who argue it’s still too high and accused the White House of accounting gimmicks, leaving the two sides far apart and drifting even further as an informal deadline for a deal nears.

What We're Reading

Biden tells David Brooks why he’s backing big progressive packages (The New York Times’ David Brooks)

Office of Personnel Management, OMB still missing Senate-confirmed leaders (The Post’s Lisa Rein)

Where's Joe

He awarded the Medal of Honor to Army Col. RALPH PUCKETT. Afterward, he held a bilateral meeting with South Korean President MOON JAE-IN.

The U.S. delegation included Secretary of State Antony Blinken, national security adviser JAKE SULLIVAN , National Security Council Coordinator for the Indo-Pacific KURT CAMPBELL, National Security Council Senior Director for East Asia and Oceania EDGARD KAGAN. Later on, the two presidents held a press conference.

Where's Kamala

She hosted a meeting with Moon in the morning. Deputy national security adviser to the vice president PHIL GORDON, deputy chief of staff to the vice president MICHAEL FUCHS, Acting Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian & Pacific Affairs SUNG KIM , and special adviser to the vice president for East Asia and the Pacific NANCY LEOU attended.

The Oppo Book

Deputy Commerce Secretary DON GRAVES violated one of Biden’s workplace policies when he was serving as a counselor to the then-vice president.

In a 2020 PBS Frontline interview , Graves said that back in 2014, he was traveling with Biden ahead of the midterm elections — during a weekend that conflicted with his daughter’s birthday party.

“So we’re in Miami. The birthday party is happening,” Graves said. “We just finished up an event. We’re getting ready to fly back to D.C. But it’s, you know, it’s an hour and a half or so flight to D.C., so I’m going to miss the party.”

Graves ended up calling into the party via FaceTime. While he was singing “Happy Birthday,” he caught Biden’s attention.

“He says, ‘Don, who are you singing ‘Happy Birthday’ to?’ And I said, ‘Oh, it’s my — it’s my youngest,’” Graves explained.

Biden proceeded to grab the phone to speak to Graves’ daughter directly: “Tori, I am so sorry. I’m so sorry that I kept your father away from your birthday party. I will absolutely make it up to you. You will see him later on tonight. I’m telling him now, he can’t do any more work for me today. He has to get home and get to you.”

Graves said Biden informed him of a longstanding workplace policy he had in the Senate that he hadn’t yet shared with vice presidential staff: “I won’t allow you to miss family events. You can’t miss your anniversary. You can’t miss birthdays. You can’t miss recitals or games. If you’re missing something on behalf of me, that’s a real problem,” he said, according to Graves.

“And if I find out that you’ve missed something, any one of these big events for your family because you’re doing something to help me, you’ll be fired on the spot,” he said.

After that incident, Biden sent a memo to White House staff about the policy — though he replaced the “you’ll be fired” line with, “I’ll be very disappointed.”

HELP US OUT — Do you have a story — that’s potentially embarrassing but not too mean or serious — you think we should use for an "Oppo Book" item? Email us transitiontips@politico.com.

MEA CULPA: Thursday’s edition of West Wing Playbook accidentally misgendered the staffer who crawled behind Interior Secretary DEB HAALAND on “Late Night with SETH MEYERS.” The staffer is a woman. Our apologies.

Trivia Answer

GEORGE W. BUSH hosted a 100k bike ride from 2011-2019.

We want your tips, but we also want your feedback as we transition to West Wing Playbook. What should we be covering in this newsletter that we’re not? What are we getting wrong? Please let us know.

Edited by Emily Cadei

 

Follow us on Twitter

Alex Thompson @AlexThomp

Theodoric Meyer @theodoricmeyer

Allie Bice @alliebice

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO West Wing Playbook

May 18,2021 10:53 pm - Tuesday

Avoiding the next Solyndra

May 17,2021 11:05 pm - Monday

Biden's coming court conundrum

May 14,2021 11:05 pm - Friday

The world’s most powerful local paper

May 13,2021 11:14 pm - Thursday

Psaki successor sweepstakes

May 12,2021 10:34 pm - Wednesday

The Hillbilly enmity