All over the map

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Monday Aug 22,2022 10:01 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Aug 22, 2022 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Nick Taylor-Vaisey

Send tips | Subscribe here | Follow Politico Canada

Thanks for reading Ottawa Playbook. I'm your host, Nick Taylor-Vaisey. We start the week with a deep dive into proposed new federal riding boundaries. Don't miss ANDY BLATCHFORD's must-read profile of DAVID COHEN, hot off the presses and reaching back to the streets of Philadelphia. And KEVIN VICKERS raises eyebrows with a tweet.

Did someone forward you this edition? Click here to sign up for your own subscription to our free newsletter.

DRIVING THE DAY

122 FEISTY ARGUMENTS — Ontario's federal riding redistribution commission slipped its proposal onto the internet on Friday. And it's a doozy. Few corners of the province escaped substantial boundary changes. Some of them could conceivably swing an election.

Also, Toronto lost a riding even as Ontario gained a seat in the overall count. Buckle up. We've got the highlights.

— The search for red flags: Canada's once-a-decade exercise in political cartography attempts to achieve roughly equal representation for citizens in each province. Today we're zeroing in on Ontario, but every other province has rolled out its proposals. ( Here's our look at New Brunswick in June.)

It doesn't suffer from the intense gerrymandering commonplace south of the border. But ask an MP about a substantial redraw and they'll privately, and sometimes publicly, vent opinions about what a handful of unelected commissioners have to say.

— Who did the drawing: The thankless task of pissing people off fell to three people: LYNNE LEITCH, a Superior Court justice from London who chairs the commission. The other members are KAREN BIRD, a poli-sci prof at McMaster University in Hamilton, and PETER LOEWEN, the director of the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy.

But it's not just the elected people who have skin in the game. Party activists read the fine print. Municipalities want to ensure maximum representation (see: Fredericton city council, which wants a riding all to itself ). Community associations don't want to see neighborhoods split between MPs. Public hearings can get feisty.

This process won't be finalized until at least April 2024. Which means politicos have plenty of time to ask key questions: Do the new boundaries divide communities in confusing ways? Do the proposed names make any sense?

Most importantly for political parties who will pore over last election's poll-by-poll results: Where are they newly vulnerable? Where can they pick up seats?

10 TRENDS TO WATCH — Throw a dart at the redraw and you'll find a talker of a tweak — or overhaul — to a boundary or a name. Here's what jumped out at Playbook.

— Toronto loses a seat: The country's biggest city would drop to 24 MPs from 25, a reduction that might satisfy non-Torontonians — but has fired up MPs in the city. JOHN MCKAY, the 25-year rep of Scarborough–Guildwood, called the new map "outrageous" in a conversation with the Toronto Star.

But it's trends in McKay's neck of woods that the commission is trying to solve for in its redraw. The suburb of Scarborough — bias alert: your Playbook host hails from the veteran Liberal's district — is shrinking in places.

The burb's overall population ticked up to 629,941 from 625,698, but that growth was uneven. Half of the six ridings in the Scarborough region saw population drops between census counts, and all six have fallen below the per-riding population "quota" of 116,590 that guided redistribution. Eighteen of 25 ridings across the 416 also fell beneath that quota.

— Elsewhere in the city: Changes are coming to the Beaches–East York riding held by Liberal MP NATHANIEL ERSKINE-SMITH, the chair of the party's Toronto caucus.

The commissioners propose a new name, The Beaches–East York, which further entrenches the federal position on an eternal debate in east-end Toronto: Is it The Beaches or The Beach?

Voters might also say goodbye to Toronto–St. Paul's, a riding name that dates back 89 years, in favor of the proposed St. Clair–Mount Pleasant. And Parkdale–High Park becomes Taiaiako'n–High Park, in honor of an ancient Mohawk-Seneca village.

— A shift for Windsor: The sprawling Chrysler assembly plant in the gritty border town will no longer fall in the riding repped for 20 years by NDP MP BRIAN MASSE (a former Chrysler employee). Windsor–Tecumseh's gain is Windsor–West's loss, and it's not symbolic. The union-heavy polls near that plant have leaned heavily to the NDP.

— Lakeshore politics: The current map includes Etobicoke–Lakeshore and Mississauga–Lakeshore. The proposed map adds the L-word to three more ridings along Lake Ontario in Oakville, Burlington and Hamilton. Snark ensued.

— How it might change the House: One poll-by-poll geek took a stab at transposing the 2021 results onto the new electoral map. He notes a handful of potential battles to watch.

— What comes next: Public participation. The commission has scheduled a mix of virtual and in-person hearings. Sparks could fly at the Scarborough Civic Center on Oct. 18 at 6:30.

What do you love about the proposed boundaries? What do you absolutely hate? Which riding rejig would be most consequential on Election Day? Tell us everything .

WHO IS DAVID COHEN? — POLITICO's ANDY BLATCHFORD has spent months watching the U.S. ambo as he settles into life as JOE BIDEN's man at Lornado, the luxurious Rockcliffe residence for the ambassador with a prime view of the Ottawa River.

Blatchford's new profile of Cohen traces his journey to Ottawa from his earliest days as chief of staff to then-Philadelphia mayor ED RENDELL, when the duo was on a mission in the 1990s to save the city from bankruptcy.

At the time, Cohen and Rendell were followed closely by Philly investigative journalist BUZZ BISSINGER , whose "A Prayer for the City" insider look at city hall described the chief of staff at times as a "bloodless prick," "head henchman," and "boy wonder."

Blatchford caught up with Rendell and a cast of characters who've watched Cohen through the years — including Canadians who are getting to know America's top envoy.

Here's some of what he learned.

— He's a reader: As Rendell's right hand, Cohen took meetings with city commissioners in a bid to balance the books. “Commissioners learned very quickly that they couldn't shuck and jive David,” Rendell told Blatchford. “David read all their material, all their reports, all their data and he knew them as well as they did going in… That made him respected and admired by the staff. Also a little bit feared — but feared in a good way.”

If you're a Canadian who hopes to persuade the ambo, are you taking notes?

— Cohen doesn't like to talk about Cohen: “I’m very happy talking about the president, talking about the prime minister, talking about policy issues,” he told Blatchford. “But I'm not in this job, I haven’t been in any of my jobs, to talk about me.”

— A common question: “I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been asked the question, on or off the record, of — just where does Canada stand with the United States?”

Read the full story here, where Cohen answers that very question (and much, much more).

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS

— German Chancellor OLAF SCHOLZ is in Canada, where he'll spend the day in Montreal and Toronto with Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU and a clutch of ministers. The pair appeared to spend part of Sunday evening at a Syrian restaurant in Outremont.

9:30 a.m. Trudeau will hold a bilateral meeting with Scholz in Montreal. Also in on the confab: Deputy PM CHRYSTIA FREELAND, Foreign Minister MÉLANIE JOLY, Innovation Minister FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE, and Natural Resources Minister JONATHAN WILKINSON.

11:15 a.m. Trudeau will hold a joint media availability with Scholz. Freeland will join.

1:55 p.m. Trudeau will visit an artificial intelligence research center with Scholz. Champagne and Wilkinson will also be in attendance.

4 p.m. Seniors Minister KAMAL KHERA is in Port Coquitlam, B.C., for a funding announcement.

5 p.m. (6 p.m. AT) Tory leadership candidate PIERRE POILIEVRE continues his Atlantic swing with a meet and greet in Moncton. (Poilievre appears to have met JEREMY MACKENZIE, founder of the extremist group Diagolon, at a Nova Scotia event on Saturday. Poilievre later denounced extremists.)

7:30 p.m. Trudeau will host an official dinner in Toronto for Scholz.

For your radar

WORTH REPEATING — Financial Post editor KEVIN CARMICHAEL was in guest chair on the latest Herle Burly pod for smart and detailed discussion on inflation, productivity and lessons for next time we could learn from the CERB.

Near the close of the conversation, Carmichael unloaded when asked for insight into the federal finance department.

“There’s so little transparency around what these guys do,” he said. “They have this sort of fake transparency in a way. They’re out there. The ministers are running all over the place, but they’re not telling us anything. They’re not actually communicating with the broader public. They’re just running around sort of restating stuff they’re popping out in press releases, their communication is severely inauthentic, very very message focused, so you don’t know what they’re doing. You don’t know what’s behind all their decisions.”

Carmichael goes on to say that although CHRYSTIA FREELAND is the first finance minister since 2000 that he hasn’t interviewed, he does not feel compelled to do so.

“You can’t get an authentic comment of any sort out of a Trudeau minister,” he said.

(They paused to note Herle’s pod is an extreme exception with outings in the past year or so from FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE, JONATHAN WILKINSON, SEAMUS O’REGAN and ANITA ANAND.)Carmichael continued: “I have no need to talk to a Trudeau minister because I don’t have any confidence they’re going to tell me anything interesting. They’re not going to tell me anything I can’t read in the budget or their press releases, so why bother? And I think that’s a shame, frankly. They clearly have decided that’s the way they want to do things.”

Watch the episode here.

— In related listening: CPAC's new anchor MICHAEL SERAPIO is a guest on The Hot Room where talk turned to ministerial talking points.

FOR THE RECORD — PM JUSTIN TRUDEAU's new nominee for the Supreme Court, MICHELLE O’BONSAWIN, filled out an application questionnaire just like every other aspiring judge in the appointments system introduced in 2016.

O'Bonsawin, a Franco-Ontarien Abenaki member of the Odanak First Nation, is an expert in mental health, Gladue principles, labor and employment law, human rights, and privacy law. She'd be leaving her post as a judge of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in Ottawa.

— On the Constitution: In her questionnaire, O'Bonsawin articulated her view of the role of a judge in a constitutional democracy — always a talker for scholars, lawyers and critics of the bench leery of so-called judicial activism.. Here's part of that response:

"A judge must continuously interpret the Constitution as a living and breathing document that is reflective of the beliefs and aspirations of generations since its original implementation. The Constitution should not be used as an impediment to individual rights. It must be interpreted in a manner that addresses issues that were not foreseen when the Constitution was first drafted.

"However, the main objective of the Constitution is to treat people equally under the law and the only way a judge can do so is to always be aware, open-minded and to interpret it as an ever-evolving document for those it seeks to protect as well as those who seek it for protection."

MEDIA ROOM

— The Toronto Star's STEPHANIE LEVITZ on what's next for the Tories after a bruising leadership race. She finds some Tory MPs worried about a staff exodus to the Office of the Leader of the Opposition.

BIANCA BHARTI looks at what the latest cost-of-living reveal about the Liberal government’s overhaul of child care.

— On The Hub Roundtable during a conversation on health care policy, SEAN SPEER explains why Canadians ought to be paying closer attention to the Ford government’s pledge to disrupt the “status quo” on health care delivery.

The Washington Post weighed in on LISA LAFLAMME. The CTV controversy was also the subject of STACY LEE KONG’s Friday Things.

Related: Former broadcaster JENNIFER SINGH on the politics of hair, and former Bell Media TV personality DANIELLE GRAHAM telling the story of her dismissal. The Toronto Sun's BRIAN LILLEY floats a theory on LaFlamme's exit.

— The CBC’s ALEX PANETTA read JARED KUSHNER’s new memoir and uncovered the U.S. take on the closed-door renegotiation of NAFTA.

— Finally, here’s CHANTAL HÉBERT on Conservatives and the environment : “The low profile of climate change as an issue in the leadership campaign reflects a long-standing disconnect between the conservative base that will be selecting the party’s next leader and Canadians in general.”

PROZONE

For POLITICO Pro s, our latest policy newsletter: The week ahead: Overseas guests on the PM's agenda.

In other news for s: 

It's on: U.S. enters the ring to battle China on clean energy.
Trudeau on Germany's short-term energy crunch: 'Not a whole lot we can do.’
Businesses sent scrambling amid GSP gridlock.
U.N. chief warns Russia not to cut nuclear plant from Ukraine’s power grid.

SUMMERTIME READS

Here’s our summer 2022 reading list so far

Send us your reading suggestions — your brain food and your guilty pleasure! We'll share them here.

PLAYBOOKERS

Birthdays: Former Reform MP ELWIN HERMANSON is 70 today. HBD + 1 to Navigator's GRAHAM FOX (from his DM sister, CHRISTIANE ).

Spotted: Former sergeant-at-arms KEVIN VICKERS, who once dabbled in New Brunswick politics as Liberal leader, firing off this tweet in response to GR guy GREG MACEACHERN, who linked to a CBC News story about an Ottawa police officer who resigned after facing charges for sexual assault:

"2% of any given profession in society is composed of social deviants. As past SAA I can tell you this is true among MPs of the Liberal Party and other Parties. I also believe the Liberal Party stands for great values as I do of Ottawa Police."

Ontario Liberal MPs, hanging out in Niagara Falls.

JODY WILSON-RAYBOULD (bow) and pal JANE PHILPOTT (stern) out on Big Rideau.

“Fairly committed mask-wearer” LUCY VAN OLDENBARNEVELD isolating with Covid … Liberal MP SEAN CASEY, hitched … 19-year-old JACOB SOLOMON, running to be Ottawa mayor.

Former Nova Scotia politician and current GR guy JAMIE BAILLIE, hanging in Boston with Consul General RODGER CUZNER.

The Canadian Association of Broadcasters, raising a stink about the CBC and Radio-Canada's licence renewals. The private sector broadcasters want an end to advertising and branded content on the public broadcaster.

Media mentions: JON WILLING has departed the Citizen/Sun newsroom to teach journalism at Algonquin College.

In memoriam: ROSEMARY SPEIRS has died. A trailblazing journalist with the Star and Globe, she was also an author and the founding chair of Equal Voice.

In a remembrance, here’s Equal Voice : “Always humble, yet fiercely determined, Rosemary successfully turned people’s attention to the issue all the while facing immense cynicism and sexism that was reflective of a time when even fewer women were elected than today.”

“The Speirs name should be in every Canadian history book,” former MP SHEILA COPPS writes in the Star. “Rosemary wrote what she lived and lived what she wrote.”

TRIVIA

Friday’s answer: The raid at Dieppe. Here’s an essay from MP ERIN O’TOOLE on remembrance.

Props to BRIAN GILBERTSON, BEN ROTH, BRAD WRIGHT, TRACY SALMON, DEAN PETERS, STEPHEN KAROL, JOANNA PLATER, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, DOUG RICE, PATRICK DION and JOHN ECKER. 

Today’s question: Name the wild-eyed guest of honor a U.S. ambassador DAVID COHEN's annual July 4 garden party in Ottawa this year.

Send your answers to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

Playbook wouldn’t happen without Luiza Ch. Savage and editor Sue Allan.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Andy Blatchford @AndyBlatchford

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Aug 19,2022 10:00 am - Friday

Keep calm, pack carry-on

Aug 18,2022 10:00 am - Thursday

Jean Charest, looking west

Aug 17,2022 10:00 am - Wednesday

'Welcome back to the bear pit'

Aug 16,2022 10:01 am - Tuesday

That's the kind of day it's been

Aug 15,2022 10:00 am - Monday

A radical idea for the capital city

Aug 12,2022 10:15 am - Friday

Stuck in the middle

Aug 11,2022 10:00 am - Thursday

The case for strong mayors