A right honorable brouhaha

From: POLITICO Ottawa Playbook - Thursday Mar 16,2023 10:01 am
A daily look inside Canadian politics and power.
Mar 16, 2023 View in browser
 
Ottawa Playbook

By Nick Taylor-Vaisey, Maura Forrest and Zi-Ann Lum

Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Nick | Follow Politico Canada

Thanks for reading the Ottawa Playbook. I'm your host, Nick Taylor-Vaisey, with Maura Forrest and Zi-Ann Lum. Today, a brand new "special rapporteur" starts his work. Plus, Conservatives are fighting over a nomination in southwestern Ontario. Also, the prime minister isn't keen on a universal basic income.

DRIVING THE DAY

BECAUSE OF COURSE — When Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU told the nation on March 6 that he would appoint a "special rapporteur" on alleged foreign interference, he used many adjectives: independent, eminent, unimpeachable, impartial, respected. Trudeau later promised to consult opposition parties on his pick.

The pressure was on to find the least offensive person for the job, a rapporteur whose rapporting would neutralize the hot takes of PIERRE POILIEVRE or JAGMEET SINGH.

— A contender: At the time, Playbook spotted NORMAN SPECTOR's speculation that DAVID JOHNSTON was the man for the job. Seemed plausible enough.

Johnston taught the law for decades. He drafted the terms of reference for the public inquiry into the Airbus affair. A Conservative PM appointed him governor general. And he brought the nascent federal leaders' debate commission to life.

Google his name and up pops a Globe and Mail op-ed from 2010 that's as relevant now as then: "David Johnston is no partisan appointee." (The byline? Spector, coincidentally.)

— Was there ever any doubt? Trudeau dropped the news Wednesday. Johnston was his man. And why shouldn't he be? Who doesn't love him? His grandson calls him Grandpa Book. He wrote the book on empathy. Not that this next bona fide qualifies him to dig into foreign interference, but did you know he once captained the Harvard hockey team?

So trustworthy.

So eminent.

So respected.

So unimpeachable.

— On second thought: The thread that spread like wildfire among Trudeau's critics came from the Globe's ANDREW COYNE.

Trudeau and Johnston aren't exactly strangers, he wrote. The PM has announced funding for Johnston's foundation. The former GG has ties to the Trudeau Foundation. Even if it's all above board, goes the argument, surely there was another able appointee up to the task.

"It is not the responsibility of others to overlook those connections," Coyne wrote. "This is the foundation of public ethics rules. It is for the office holder to act at all times in a way that leaves no room for any doubt about his/her integrity — not for the public to stifle their doubts."

— The wet blankets: The Tories sure weren't enthused. JENNI BYRNE, the architect of Poilievre's leadership campaign and a major player in the party, spat some fire. Deputy leader MELISSA LANTSMAN and former leader ANDREW SCHEER claim to know where this is going — and it's not a public inquiry.

Poilievre was busy pressing flesh in B.C. on Wednesday. His social media remained silent on Johnston's appointment (for now). He did preemptively dismiss the then-unnamed rapporteur as "a fake position doing fake work."

Will the naming of the rapporteur turn down the heat at a procedure and House affairs committee deadlocked on whether or not Trudeau chief of staff KATIE TELFORD should testify about foreign interference allegations?

Two words: Hell no.

REFLECTIONS ON CHINA — Google search interest in Johnson spiked Wednesday afternoon after the news. Googlers might have dug up Johnston's 2013 speech to the Canada China Business Council at a banquet in Beijing.

Johnston remarked on "a Canadian presence in China to an extent seldom seen before." He namechecked recent trips to the republic by Ottawa mayor JIM WATSON, Tory Cabinet ministers ED FAST and JOHN BAIRD, and even the National Arts Centre orchestra.

A reminder of the way it was, across the political spectrum.

— A different tone: As he prepared to leave his GG post in 2017, Johnston was forced to defend a visit to China. He met with Chinese President XI JINPING on the same day the world learned of the death of 61-year-old Chinese democracy activist LIU XIAOBO — a Nobel Peace Prize laureate.

“We spoke at some length and obviously we had a different opinion about it, but it was a conversation that lasted for some time,” he said at the time, per CTV News.

“He went through [in] some detail, and in a very clear fashion, China’s system of the rule of law, the features of their criminal justice system that they regard as offenses, the process that was taken with respect to our friend, the winner of the peace prize, and some of his concerns about the peace prize itself, and due process as he saw it."

THE SMALL PRINT — Per the PM's announcement: "Mr. Johnston will have a wide mandate to look into foreign interference in the last two federal general elections and make expert recommendations on how to further protect our democracy and uphold Canadians’ confidence in it."

—The promise: "The Government of Canada will comply with and implement his public recommendations, which could include a formal inquiry, a judicial review, or another independent review process."

— The timeline: "We will be working with Mr. Johnston to finalize his mandate in the coming days, and it will be made public." Translation: TBD.

TODAY'S HIGHLIGHTS

— Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU will be in Toronto.

10:30 a.m. NDP leader JAGMEET SINGH will speak at a nursing class at York University.

11 a.m. Senators VICTOR OH and YUEN PAU WOO, in partnership with Action! Chinese Canadians Together, will hold a press conference to announce a National Remembrance Ceremony to mark the 100th Anniversary of the Introduction of the Chinese Exclusion Act .

11:45 a.m. Singh will speak to reporters.

1:45 p.m. Trudeau will gather former NAFTA Advisory Council members and Canada-U.S. relations experts to pool intel on the state of the bilateral relationship and its future. Deputy PM CHRYSTIA FREELAND will be there, as will Trade Minister MARY NG.

7 p.m. Trudeau will participate in a town hall with firefighters, hosted by the International Association of Fire Fighters.

9:30 p.m. (6:30 p.m. PT) Fresh off a Wednesday night fundraiser on Vancouver Island, Tory leader PIERRE POILIEVRE will spend part of this evening at a meet-and-greet in Victoria.

For your radar

AWKWARD IN OXFORD — Who said byelections are boring? DAVE MACKENZIE's retirement has opened a seat in southwestern Ontario. There's no date for the vote to fill the vacancy in Oxford, but the Tories are already annoying each other.

The party rejected GERRIT VAN DORLAND, a Hill staffer to Tory MP JEREMY PATZER and potential party candidate whose platform emphasizes faith, family and freedom. Van Dorland has the support of five CPC MPs: Patzer, LESLYN LEWIS, ROSEMARIE FALK, DAMIEN KUREK, and TOM KMIEC (his former Hill boss).

Van Dorland worked for Lewis's party leadership campaign in 2022. His social conservative voter base could play kingmaker in the contest.

— The party line: CPC d-comm SARAH FISCHER told the Canadian Press that Van Dorland's run for the candidacy was "barred for failing to provide information such as a list of social media accounts and comments he made online."

— Frenemies: Two competitors for the candidacy are urging the party to reinstate their rival. ARPAN KHANNA tweeted a letter saying as much. Khanna is also the party's national outreach chair (and counts ANDREW SCHEER as a supporter). He's taken heat for a lack of historical ties to the riding.

Fellow contender RICK ROTH, a former Hill and Queen's Park senior staffer who is married to Poilievre leadership campaign d-comm GINNY ROTH, released his own statement that appeared to place Khanna squarely in its crosshairs.

"Whether the party sees it or not, Gerrit represents and has the support of a massive community here in Oxford," Roth said. "I know this because I've spoken to thousands of residents in the past few months, and many have told me their stories and connection to Gerrit and his family; through church, school or other community organizations."

Van Dorland's rejection, Roth said, "sets a dangerous path of ignoring grassroots voices for a preferred parachute candidate with no connection to our community."

Shots fired. The so-con vote is a powerful incentive in Oxford.

LOBBY WATCH — Lobbyists reliably produce a logjam of communication reports on the 15th of every month, which is the deadline for disclosing any meetings held with public office holders in the previous calendar month. Many lobbyists tick a box that auto-posts their reports at the mid-month mark.

Wednesday brought a pile of meetings dating mostly to February. By the end of the day, in-house and consultant lobbyists had posted a whopping 1,814.

— The biggest filer: The Canadian Labour Congress posted 146 reports on Wednesday, including eight ministers, 110 MPs and 25 senators.

— Busy bee(tles): Volkswagen and its hired consultants filed a dollop of communication reports with ministers, political staffers and senior-level bureaucrats.

They've racked up 41 since November, when the company first recorded a meeting with Innovation Minister FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE, his deputy minister SIMON KENNEDY and Finance DM MICHAEL SABIA.

Kennedy has appeared in 27 of those reports. Champagne was noted in 11. COLETTE KAMINSKY, the associate assistant deputy minister for Innovation Canada, popped up in 14. Another AADM, MARY GREGORY from ISED's industry sector, was in six.

FOR THE RECORD — Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU offered some unusually candid thoughts about a universal basic income yesterday, saying he tends to prefer “targeted” assistance.

Early in the pandemic, when calls for a basic income were gaining traction, Trudeau opted to stick with such measures as the CERB, directed at particular segments of the population. Then, in April 2021, Liberal delegates at a policy convention overwhelmingly endorsed a resolution calling for the establishment of a universal basic income.

At the time, Trudeau didn’t shut the door.

Since then, the issue has largely fallen off the radar. And when the PM was asked for his opinion during a Wednesday town hall in rural Newfoundland, he was decidedly cool to the idea. He pointed instead to targeted measures like the Canada child benefit, C$10-a-day child care and the Canada workers benefit, which he called a “more nuanced approach.”

— Here’s part of what he had to say: 

“We were very interested in the idea of basic income, because it goes with the philosophy that we’ve had of making sure that everyone is able to cover their basic needs. What we found, though, in looking into it is that it is so difficult to compare and contrast different experiences, different families, different needs, and to distill it down to one number that would be the same across the country.

“I know there’s a few different projects going on with basic income pilots and we’re looking at the data on that. But we’re trying to … give people what they need in a targeted way rather than just a universal brush way.”

— Location, location: The PM spent the day in Clarenville, Nfld., a town of 6,300 people on Newfoundland’s east coast, about a two-hour drive from St. John’s.

It’s worth noting Conservative Leader PIERRE POILIEVRE was in Clarenville not three weeks ago, where he held his own version of a town hall (fewer questions, more speechifying). He also paid a visit to the town in May 2022, during the Conservative leadership race.

It’s a lot of big-name attention for a small town. But Clarenville is in the riding of Bonavista–Burin–Trinity, currently held by Liberal MP CHURENCE ROGERS, which the Conservatives targeted in the 2021 election.

Poll aggregator 338Canada gives the Liberals a six-point lead in the riding — 46 to 40 percent — which tracks with the 2021 election results. But that’s a considerable drop from 2015, when the Liberals won 82 percent of the vote.

— One other note: The name of Bonavista–Burin–Trinity is likely to change to Terra Nova–The Peninsulas under the proposed redistribution of federal ridings. Just so you know.

MEDIA ROOM

— Maj.-Gen. DANY FORTIN is suing the government — and the prime minister — for C$6 million months after he was acquitted of sexual assault by a Quebec court.

Also on the list of defendants: Privy Council clerk JANICE CHARETTE, Chief of the Defense Staff Gen. WAYNE EYRE, former president of the Public Health Agency of Canada IAIN STEWART, former health minister PATTY HAJDU, former defense minister HARJIT SAJJAN, former defense DM JODY THOMAS and former Sajjan chief of staff GEORGE YOUNG.

— From The Tyee: B.C. approves new LNG plant, introduces oil and gas emission caps

— The Toronto Star's SUSAN DELACOURT on DAVID JOHNSTON's next gig: When it comes to trust, Justin Trudeau’s point man on election interference wrote the book

DON BRAID reports on the salaries paid to Alberta Premier DANIELLE SMITH's senior staff. Smith's chief of staff, MARSHALL SMITH, earns C$220,000 a year. Count those disclosures as an election year win for the NDP.

PLAYBOOKERS

Birthdays: HBD to economist and banker MARK CARNEY. Former Conservative MP LEONA ALLESLEV also celebrates today.

Do you have a birthday coming up? Does a colleague? Send us the dates and we'll tell the world.

Spotted: A curious job posting at the Global News that recently laid off five women from its national online team … Liberal MP YVONNE JONES with a birthday visit from her boss, as well as caucus colleagues GUDIE HUTCHINGS and JOANNE THOMPSON. … CATHERINE MCKENNA on an ebike in London.

A Business Council of Canada delegation meeting Sen. MIKE CRAPO (R-Utah) in Washington. The BCC gang included ROB WILDEBOER, executive chair and co-founder of Martinrea International; VICTOR DODIG, president and CEO of CIBC; and BLAKE HUTCHESON, president and CEO of OMERS.

European Commission President URSULA VON DER LEYEN noting her Canada visit and the need for “like-minded partners” during a speech Wednesday at the European Parliament Plenary.

Manitoba MLA BRAD MICHALESKI announcing he won’t run in the fall election. As CBC reports, he's the 14th of 36 PC MLAs to decide against seeking re-election.

Movers and shakers: LESLIE WEIR has been reappointed Librarian and Archivist of Canada for a four-year term, effective Aug. 30.

NATIONAL's JASON CRAIK is lobbying for provincial lottery corporations. Top priority: “The enactment of legislation to protect Canadians from illegal operators [and] ongoing operations of illegal gambling websites.” … Rubicon managing partner ANDREW BALFOUR is repping Hydro One, which wants federal funding for rural and remote transmission development.

PROZONE

If you’re a , don’t miss our latest policy newsletter from MAURA FORREST: Trudeau teases 2023 budget

In other Pro headlines:
Chips supply chain is key concern for Europe's green transition, EU draft says.
Who are the most vulnerable House Democrats?
EPA imposes pollution limits on power plants, industrial sources in 23 states.
Nothing to see here: EU shrugs off Silicon Valley Bank collapse.
Buttigieg 'concerned' about increase in airline close calls.

On the Hill

Parliament returns March 20.

Find the latest House committees here

Keep track of Senate committees here

TRIVIA

Wednesday’s answer: None of the Famous 5 was named to the Senate. However, as many readers noted, the five Alberta women were named honorary senators in 2009.

Props to MATTHEW DUBÉ, ANNE-MARIE STACEY, SHEILA GERVAIS, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, SHAUGHN MCARTHUR, JOANNA PLATER, DOUG RICE and LAURA JARVIS.

Today’s question: What Canadian politician described swapping parties this way: “It’s one of those things … kind of like getting divorced without ever telling the person you’re getting separated … when you don’t even dislike them necessarily.”

Send your answer to ottawaplaybook@politico.com

Want to grab the attention of movers and shakers on Parliament Hill? Want your brand in front of a key audience of Ottawa influencers? Playbook can help. Contact Jesse Shapiro to find out how: jshapiro@politico.com

Playbook wouldn’t happen: Without Luiza Ch. Savage and Sue Allan.

 

Follow us on Twitter

Nick Taylor-Vaisey @TaylorVaisey

Sue Allan @susan_allan

Maura Forrest @MauraForrest

Zi-Ann Lum @ziannlum

POLITICO Canada @politicoottawa

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to .

More emails from POLITICO Ottawa Playbook

Mar 15,2023 10:01 am - Wednesday

And so on to infinity

Mar 14,2023 10:01 am - Tuesday

230 budget asks

Mar 13,2023 10:00 am - Monday

Beer budget

Mar 10,2023 11:02 am - Friday

Theater on the Hill

Mar 09,2023 11:01 am - Thursday

The pre-budget song and dance

Mar 08,2023 11:01 am - Wednesday

Another kind of Eurovision

Mar 07,2023 11:01 am - Tuesday

PMJT's not-an-inquiry